Subramanian Sujha, Gakunga Robai, Kibachio Joseph, Gathecha Gladwell, Edwards Patrick, Ogola Elijah, Yonga Gerald, Busakhala Naftali, Munyoro Esther, Chakaya Jeremiah, Ngugi Nancy, Mwangi Nyawira, Von Rege Daniel, Wangari Lili-Marie, Wata David, Makori Robert, Mwangi Julius, Mwanda Walter
Public Health Research Division, RTI International, Waltham, MA, United States of America.
Independent Research Scientist, Nairobi, Kenya.
PLoS One. 2018 Jan 5;13(1):e0190113. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190113. eCollection 2018.
The prevalence of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) is rising in low- and middle-income countries, including Kenya, disproportionately to the rest of the world. Our objective was to quantify patient payments to obtain NCD screening, diagnosis, and treatment services in the public and private sector in Kenya and evaluate patients' ability to pay for the services.
We collected payment data on cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer, and respiratory diseases from Kenyatta National Hospital, the main tertiary public hospital, and the Kibera South Health Center-a public outpatient facility, and private sector practitioners and hospitals. We developed detailed treatment frameworks for each NCD and used an itemization cost approach to estimate payments. Patient affordability metrics were derived from Kenyan government surveys and national datasets. Results compare public and private costs in U.S. dollars. NCD screening costs ranged from $4 to $36, while diagnostic procedures, particularly for breast and cervical cancer, were substantially more expensive. Annual hypertension medication costs ranged from $26 to $234 and $418 to $987 in public and private facilities, respectively. Stroke admissions ($1,874 versus $16,711) and dialysis for chronic kidney disease ($5,338 versus $11,024) were among the most expensive treatments. Cervical and breast cancer treatment cost for stage III (curative approach) was about $1,500 in public facilities and more than $7,500 in the private facilities. A large proportion of Kenyans aged 15 to 49 years do not have health insurance, which makes NCD services unaffordable for most people given the overall high cost of services relative to income (average household expenditure per adult is $413 per annum).
There is substantial variation in patient costs between the public and private sectors. Most NCD diagnosis and treatment costs, even in the public sector, represent a substantial economic burden that can result in catastrophic expenditures.
包括肯尼亚在内的低收入和中等收入国家,非传染性疾病(NCDs)的患病率正在上升,其增长速度与世界其他地区不成比例。我们的目标是量化肯尼亚患者为获得公共和私营部门的非传染性疾病筛查、诊断和治疗服务所支付的费用,并评估患者支付这些服务费用的能力。
我们收集了肯尼亚主要的三级公立医院肯雅塔国家医院、基贝拉南健康中心(一个公共门诊设施)以及私营部门从业者和医院的心血管疾病、糖尿病、乳腺癌和宫颈癌以及呼吸系统疾病的支付数据。我们为每种非传染性疾病制定了详细的治疗框架,并采用分项成本法来估算支付费用。患者可承受能力指标来自肯尼亚政府调查和国家数据集。结果以美元比较了公共和私营部门的成本。非传染性疾病筛查费用从4美元到36美元不等,而诊断程序,特别是乳腺癌和宫颈癌的诊断程序,费用要高得多。公立和私立医疗机构中,每年高血压药物费用分别为26美元至234美元和418美元至987美元。中风住院治疗(1874美元对16711美元)和慢性肾病透析(5338美元对11024美元)是最昂贵的治疗项目之一。公立医疗机构中,III期宫颈癌和乳腺癌的治疗费用(根治性治疗方法)约为1500美元,私立医疗机构则超过7500美元。很大一部分15至49岁的肯尼亚人没有医疗保险,鉴于服务总成本相对于收入较高(成年人平均家庭支出为每年413美元),这使得大多数人无法承受非传染性疾病服务的费用。
公共和私营部门之间患者成本存在很大差异。即使在公共部门,大多数非传染性疾病的诊断和治疗费用也构成了巨大的经济负担,可能导致灾难性支出。