Krishnan Anup, Singh Krishan, Sharma Deep, Upadhyay Vivekanand, Singh Amit
Medical Officer (Sports Medicine), Army Sports Institute, Pune 411040, India.
Graded Specialist (Physiology), Command Hospital (Southern Command), Pune 411040, India.
Med J Armed Forces India. 2018 Jan;74(1):38-43. doi: 10.1016/j.mjafi.2017.04.004. Epub 2017 May 31.
Body cooling has been used to increase sporting performance and enhance recovery. Several studies have reported improvement in exercise capacities using forearm and hand cooling or only hand cooling. Wrist cooling has emerged as a portable light weight solution for precooling prior to sporting activity. The Astrand test for aerobic performance and the Wingate test for anaerobic performance are reliable and accurate tests for performance assessment. This study conducted on elite Indian athletes analyses the effects of wrist precooling on aerobic and anaerobic performance as tested by the Astrand test and the Wingate test before and after wrist precooling.
67 elite sportsmen were administered Wingate and Astrand test under standardised conditions with and without wrist precooling using a wrist cooling device (dhamaSPORT). Paired -test was applied to study effect on aerobic [VO (ml/min/kg)] and anaerobic performance [peak power (W/kg) and average power (W/kg)] and Cohen's was used to calculate effect size of wrist precooling.
After wrist precooling, significant increase of 0.22 ( = 0.014, 95% CI: 0.047, 0.398) in peak power (W/kg) and 0.22 ( < 0.0001, 95% CI: 0.142, 0.291) was observed in average power (W/kg). Although, an increase of 1.38 ( = 0.097, 95% CI: -0.225, 3.012) was observed in VO (ml/min/kg), wrist precooling was not significantly effective in aerobic performance. Wrist cooling effect size was smaller in VO (Cohen's = 0.21), peak power (Cohen's = 0.31) and it was larger in average power (Cohen's = 0.71).
Results show wrist precooling significantly improves anaerobic than aerobic performance of elite sportsmen.
身体降温已被用于提高运动表现和促进恢复。多项研究报告称,使用前臂和手部降温或仅手部降温可改善运动能力。手腕降温已成为一种轻便的便携式解决方案,用于在体育活动前进行预冷。有氧能力的阿斯特兰德测试和无氧能力的温盖特测试是评估运动表现的可靠且准确的测试。本研究针对印度精英运动员,分析了手腕预冷对有氧和无氧表现的影响,该影响通过手腕预冷前后的阿斯特兰德测试和温盖特测试进行评估。
67名精英运动员在标准化条件下,使用手腕冷却装置(dhamaSPORT)进行了有手腕预冷和无手腕预冷的温盖特测试和阿斯特兰德测试。采用配对检验来研究对手有氧[VO(毫升/分钟/千克)]和无氧表现[峰值功率(瓦/千克)和平均功率(瓦/千克)]的影响,并使用科恩效应量来计算手腕预冷的效应大小。
手腕预冷后,观察到峰值功率(瓦/千克)显著增加0.22(=0.014,95%置信区间:0.047,0.398),平均功率(瓦/千克)显著增加0.22(<0.0001,95%置信区间:0.142,0.291)。尽管观察到VO(毫升/分钟/千克)增加了1.38(=0.097,95%置信区间:-0.225,3.012),但手腕预冷对有氧表现的效果并不显著。手腕冷却在VO(科恩效应量=0.21)、峰值功率(科恩效应量=0.31)方面的效应大小较小,而在平均功率方面效应大小较大(科恩效应量=0.71)。
结果表明,手腕预冷对精英运动员无氧表现的改善显著大于有氧表现。