1 Defence Research and Development, Toronto, Ontario.
2 Douglas University Institute in Mental Health, McGill University, Montréal, Quebec.
Can J Psychiatry. 2018 Sep;63(9):602-609. doi: 10.1177/0706743718760291. Epub 2018 Feb 13.
Mental disorders constitute a significant public health problem worldwide. Ensuring that those who need mental health services access them in an appropriate and timely manner is thus an important public health priority. We used data from 4 cross-sectional, nationally representative population health surveys that employed nearly identical methods to compare MHSU trends in the Canadian military versus comparable civilians.
The surveys were all conducted by Statistics Canada, approximately a decade apart (Military-2002, Military-2013, Civilian-2002, and Civilian-2012). The sample size for the pooled data across the surveys was 35,984. Comparisons across the 4 surveys were adjusted for differences in need in the 2 populations at the 2 time points.
Our findings suggested that first, in the Canadian military, there was a clear and consistent pattern of improvement (i.e., increase) in MHSU over the past decade across a variety of provider types. The magnitudes of the changes were large, representing an absolute increase of 7.15% in those seeking any professional care, corresponding to an 84% relative increase. Second, in comparable Canadian civilians, MHSU remained either unchanged or increased only slightly. Third, the increases in MHSU over time were consistently greater in the military than in the comparable civilian sample.
Our findings point to advantages with respect to MHSU of the military mental health system over the civilian system in Canada; these advantages have widened substantially over time. These findings speak strongly to the potential impact of analogous changes in other health systems, both military and civilian.
精神障碍在全球范围内构成了重大的公共卫生问题。因此,确保有需要的人能够以适当和及时的方式获得精神卫生服务,是一项重要的公共卫生优先事项。我们使用了来自 4 项横断面、全国代表性的人群健康调查的数据,这些调查采用了几乎相同的方法,比较了加拿大军队和可比平民的精神卫生服务利用趋势。
这些调查均由加拿大统计局进行,时间间隔约为 10 年(军队-2002 年、军队-2013 年、平民-2002 年和平民-2012 年)。通过对 4 项调查的数据进行汇总,样本量为 35984 人。在比较 2 个群体在 2 个时间点的需求差异时,对汇总数据进行了调整。
我们的研究结果表明,首先,在加拿大军队中,过去十年间,各种类型的提供者的精神卫生服务利用情况均呈现出明显且一致的改善(即增加)趋势。变化幅度很大,表明寻求任何专业护理的人数绝对增加了 7.15%,相对增加了 84%。其次,在可比的加拿大平民中,精神卫生服务利用情况基本保持不变或仅略有增加。第三,随着时间的推移,军队中的精神卫生服务利用增加幅度始终大于可比平民样本。
我们的研究结果表明,加拿大军队的精神卫生系统在精神卫生服务利用方面优于平民系统;而且,这些优势随着时间的推移大幅扩大。这些发现有力地证明了在其他卫生系统(包括军事和民用系统)中进行类似变革可能产生的影响。