Michalopoulos Lynn Murphy, Meinhart Melissa, Yung Justina, Barton Samuel Monroe, Wang Xinyi, Chakrabarti Urmi, Ritchey Megan, Haroz Emily, Joseph Nakita, Bass Judith, Bolton Paul
Global Health and Mental Health Unit, Social Intervention Group, Columbia University School of Social Work, New York, NY, USA.
Columbia University School of Social Work, New York, NY, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2020 Apr;21(2):406-420. doi: 10.1177/1524838018772293. Epub 2018 Apr 26.
Exposure to potentially traumatic events is a global health problem, especially in low- and middle-income countries. Assessments for symptoms resulting from trauma exposure rely heavily on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-5) criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which may not be relevant in all regions of the globe. We examined posttrauma symptoms that were not limited to Western constructs of mental health (i.e., PTSD). In a systematic review, we searched nine databases to identify posttrauma symptoms arising in qualitative literature published before July 17, 2017. A total of 17,938 records were identified and 392 met inclusion criteria. The 392 studies represented data on 400 study populations from 71 different nationalities/ethnicities. The presence and frequency of posttrauma symptoms were examined across all regions. Fisher's exact tests were also conducted to compare frequencies in posttrauma symptoms across region and gender. Based on a weighted analysis across regions, a list of global posttrauma symptoms ( = 85) was compiled into an item bank. We found that the majority of DSM-5 PTSD symptoms were mentioned across regions (with the exception of and ). Across all regions, we also found a number of symptoms mentioned that were not part of PTSD and its associated features. Findings suggest that assessing posttrauma symptoms solely based on PTSD may be limiting to global populations. Research, policy, and practice implications are discussed.
接触潜在创伤性事件是一个全球性的健康问题,在低收入和中等收入国家尤为如此。对创伤暴露所致症状的评估严重依赖于《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第五版(DSM-5)中创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的标准,而这些标准在全球所有地区可能并不适用。我们研究了不限于西方心理健康概念(即PTSD)的创伤后症状。在一项系统评价中,我们检索了九个数据库,以识别2017年7月17日前发表的定性文献中出现的创伤后症状。共识别出17938条记录,392条符合纳入标准。这392项研究代表了来自71个不同国籍/种族的400个研究人群的数据。我们对所有地区的创伤后症状的存在情况和频率进行了研究。还进行了Fisher精确检验,以比较不同地区和性别的创伤后症状频率。基于对各地区的加权分析,编制了一份包含85项全球创伤后症状的条目库。我们发现,DSM-5中大多数PTSD症状在各地区都有提及(和除外)。在所有地区,我们还发现了一些不属于PTSD及其相关特征的症状。研究结果表明,仅基于PTSD评估创伤后症状可能会限制全球人群的评估。我们还讨论了研究、政策和实践方面的意义。