March Christine, Walker Lorne W, Toto Regina L, Choi Sylvia, Reis Evelyn C, Dewar Stephanie
J Grad Med Educ. 2018 Jun;10(3):306-310. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-17-00913.1.
Patients and families can make discriminatory comments leading to physician distress. Residents receive little training in appropriate responses to such comments and may be ill equipped to respond to intolerance without alienating the individual(s) making the comments.
We assessed whether a simulated curriculum would enhance pediatrics residents' ability to effectively respond to discriminatory comments.
In the 2016-2017 academic year, we modified an existing communication skills curriculum for senior pediatrics residents. Residents engaged a simulated parent who used discriminatory speech in 4 scenarios, followed by a group debriefing. We conducted anonymous surveys to assess residents' preparedness to respond to these comments before and immediately following participation and examined their experience with discriminatory comments in the workplace.
The majority of residents reported prior experience with discriminatory comments (32 of 45 [71%] witnessed such comments, and 27 of 48 [56%] were targeted by such comments), most often regarding age, race, and ethnicity. Mean precourse scores ranged from 2.1 to 3.1 (on a 5-point scale) regarding ability to engage in a firm yet respectful dialogue, to reference the hospital code of conduct, to coach a learner to respond, and to facilitate a team debrief. Mean postcourse scores improved significantly for these questions (range 3.8-4.1). The greatest improvement was in referencing the code of conduct (2.1 versus 4.0, < .001).
Immediately after participating in simulation, pediatrics residents reported a significant improvement in self-reported readiness to respond to discriminatory comments made by a parent and reported the simulation experience was beneficial.
患者及其家属可能会发表歧视性言论,导致医生苦恼。住院医师在如何恰当回应此类言论方面接受的培训很少,可能没有足够的能力在不疏远发表言论者的情况下应对不宽容行为。
我们评估了一个模拟课程是否会提高儿科住院医师有效回应歧视性言论的能力。
在2016 - 2017学年,我们对现有的针对儿科高年级住院医师的沟通技能课程进行了修改。住院医师与一名模拟家长互动,该家长在4种场景中使用了歧视性语言,随后进行小组总结汇报。我们进行了匿名调查,以评估住院医师在参与课程之前和之后立即应对这些言论的准备情况,并考察他们在工作场所遇到歧视性言论的经历。
大多数住院医师报告有过接触歧视性言论的经历(45人中有32人[71%]目睹过此类言论,48人中有27人[56%]成为此类言论的目标对象),最常见的涉及年龄、种族和民族。关于进行坚定而尊重的对话、提及医院行为准则、指导学习者做出回应以及促进团队总结汇报的能力,课程前平均得分在2.1至3.1分(满分5分)之间。这些问题的课程后平均得分显著提高(范围为3.8 - 4.1)。最大的进步在于提及行为准则(从2.1分提高到4.0分,P <.001)。
参与模拟后,儿科住院医师报告称,他们自我报告的应对家长歧视性言论的准备情况有显著改善,并表示模拟体验是有益处的。