Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115;
Department of Sociology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2018 Jul 24;115(30):7735-7740. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1802537115. Epub 2018 Jul 9.
Influential research on the negative effects of living in a disadvantaged neighborhood assumes that its residents are socially isolated from nonpoor or "mainstream" neighborhoods, but the extent and nature of such isolation remain in question. We develop a test of neighborhood isolation that improves on static measures derived from commonly used census reports by leveraging fine-grained dynamic data on the everyday movement of residents in America's 50 largest cities. We analyze 650 million geocoded Twitter messages to estimate the home locations and travel patterns of almost 400,000 residents over 18 mo. We find surprisingly high consistency across neighborhoods of different race and income characteristics in the average travel distance (radius) and number of neighborhoods traveled to (spread) in the metropolitan region; however, we uncover notable differences in the composition of the neighborhoods visited. Residents of primarily black and Hispanic neighborhoods-whether poor or not-are far less exposed to either nonpoor or white middle-class neighborhoods than residents of primarily white neighborhoods. These large racial differences are notable given recent declines in segregation and the increasing diversity of American cities. We also find that white poor neighborhoods are substantially isolated from nonpoor white neighborhoods. The results suggest that even though residents of disadvantaged neighborhoods travel far and wide, their relative isolation and segregation persist.
有关生活在不利社区的负面影响的有影响力的研究假设,其居民与非贫困或“主流”社区在社会上是隔离的,但这种隔离的程度和性质仍存在疑问。我们开发了一种邻里隔离测试方法,该方法利用美国 50 个最大城市居民日常活动的细粒度动态数据,改进了常用人口普查报告中得出的静态措施。我们分析了 6.5 亿条地理标记的 Twitter 消息,以估计近 40 万名居民在 18 个月内的家庭住址和出行模式。我们发现,不同种族和收入特征的社区在平均出行距离(半径)和出行到的社区数量(分布)方面具有惊人的一致性;然而,我们发现访问的社区组成存在显著差异。无论是贫困与否,主要是黑人或西班牙裔社区的居民,与非贫困或白人中产阶级社区的接触都远远少于主要是白人社区的居民。考虑到最近隔离程度的下降和美国城市日益多样化,这些巨大的种族差异值得注意。我们还发现,白人贫困社区与非贫困白人社区在很大程度上是隔离的。研究结果表明,即使生活在贫困社区的居民出行范围很广,但他们的相对隔离和隔离仍然存在。