IEEE J Biomed Health Inform. 2018 Sep;22(5):1341-1349. doi: 10.1109/JBHI.2017.2777926. Epub 2017 Nov 27.
The goal of this study was to develop an algorithm that automatically quantifies motor states (off, on, dyskinesia) in Parkinson's disease (PD), based on accelerometry during a hand pronation-supination test. Clinician's ratings using the Treatment Response Scale (TRS), ranging from -3 (very Off) to 0 (On) to +3 (very dyskinetic), were used as target. For that purpose, 19 participants with advanced PD and 22 healthy persons were recruited in a single center open label clinical trial in Uppsala, Sweden. The trial consisted of single levodopa dose experiments for the people with PD (PwP), where participants were asked to perform standardized wrist rotation tests, using each hand, before and at prespecified time points after the dose. The participants used wrist sensors containing a three-dimensional accelerometer and gyroscope. Features to quantify the level, variation, and asymmetry of the sensor signals, three-level discrete wavelet transform features, and approximate entropy measures were extracted from the sensors data. At the time of the tests, the PwP were video recorded. Three movement disorder specialists rated the participants' state on the TRS. A Treatment Response Index from Sensors (TRIS) was constructed to quantify the motor states based on the wrist rotation tests. Different machine learning algorithms were evaluated to map the features derived from the sensor data to the ratings provided by the three specialists. Results from cross validation, both in tenfold and a leave-one-individual out setting, showed good predictive power of a support vector machine model and high correlation to the TRS. Values at the end tails of the TRS were under and over predicted due to the lack of observations at those values but the model managed to accurately capture the dose-effect profiles of the patients. In addition, the TRIS had good test-retest reliability on the baseline levels of the PD participants (Intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.83) and reasonable sensitivity to levodopa treatment (0.33 for the TRIS). For a series of test occasions, the proposed algorithms provided dose-effect time profiles for participants with PD, which could be useful during therapy individualization of people suffering from advanced PD.
本研究的目的是开发一种算法,基于手部旋前-旋后测试期间的加速度计,自动量化帕金森病(PD)患者的运动状态(关、开、异动症)。使用治疗反应量表(TRS)的临床医生评分作为目标,范围从-3(非常关)到 0(开)到+3(非常异动症)。为此,在瑞典乌普萨拉的一个单一中心开放性临床试验中招募了 19 名晚期 PD 患者和 22 名健康人。该试验包括 PD 患者的单次左旋多巴剂量实验(PwP),要求参与者在剂量前和剂量后预定时间点使用每只手进行标准化手腕旋转测试。参与者使用包含三维加速度计和陀螺仪的手腕传感器。从传感器数据中提取了量化传感器信号水平、变化和不对称的特征、三级离散小波变换特征和近似熵度量。在测试时,PwP 被视频记录。三位运动障碍专家根据 TRS 对参与者的状态进行评分。基于手腕旋转测试,构建了传感器治疗反应指数(TRIS)来量化运动状态。评估了不同的机器学习算法,以将从传感器数据中提取的特征映射到三位专家提供的评分。十折交叉验证和个体留一交叉验证的结果均显示支持向量机模型具有良好的预测能力,并且与 TRS 高度相关。由于缺乏这些值的观察结果,TRS 末端值的预测结果偏高或偏低,但该模型成功地准确捕捉了患者的剂量效应曲线。此外,TRIS 在 PD 患者的基线水平上具有良好的测试-重测可靠性(组内相关系数为 0.83),对左旋多巴治疗具有合理的敏感性(TRIS 为 0.33)。对于一系列测试场合,提出的算法为 PD 患者提供了剂量-效应时间曲线,这在晚期 PD 患者的个体化治疗中可能有用。