Plant Genome. 2018 Jul;11(2). doi: 10.3835/plantgenome2017.12.0112.
Genomic prediction studies incorporating genotype × environment (G×E) interaction effects are limited in durum wheat. We tested the genomic-enabled prediction accuracy (PA) of Genomic Best Linear Unbiased Predictor (GBLUP) models-six non-G × E and three G × E models-on three basic cross-validation (CV) schemes- in predicting incomplete field trials (CV2), new lines (CV1), and lines in untested environments (CV0)- in a durum wheat panel grown under yield potential, drought stress, and heat stress conditions. For CV0, three scenarios were considered: (i) leave-one environment out (CV0-Env); (ii) leave one site out (CV0-Site); and (iii) leave 1 yr out (CV0-Year). The reaction norm models with G × E effects showed higher PA than the non-G × E models. Among the CV schemes, CV2 and CV0-Env had higher PA (0.58 each) than the CV1 scheme (0.35). When the average of all the models and CV schemes were considered, among the eight traits- grain yield, thousand grain weight, grain number, days to anthesis, days to maturity, plant height, and normalized difference vegetation index at vegetative (NDVIvg) and grain filling (NDVIllg)-, plant height had the highest PA (0.68) and moderate values were observed for grain yield (0.34). The results indicated that genomic selection models incorporating G × E interaction show great promise for forward prediction and application in durum wheat breeding to increase genetic gains.
包含基因型×环境(G×E)互作效应的基因组预测研究在硬质小麦中受到限制。我们在一个硬质小麦群体中,在潜在产量、干旱胁迫和热胁迫条件下,测试了非 G×E 和三种 G×E 模型的基因组最佳线性无偏预测(GBLUP)模型的基因组启用预测准确性(PA)——在三个基本交叉验证(CV)方案中进行预测:不完全田间试验(CV2)、新系(CV1)和未经测试环境中的系(CV0)——对于 CV0,考虑了三种情况:(i)留出一个环境(CV0-Env);(ii)留出一个地点(CV0-Site);和(iii)留出一年(CV0-Year)。具有 G×E 效应的反应规范模型显示出比非 G×E 模型更高的 PA。在 CV 方案中,CV2 和 CV0-Env 的 PA 更高(分别为 0.58),而 CV1 方案的 PA 较低(0.35)。当考虑所有模型和 CV 方案的平均值时,在所有 8 个性状——籽粒产量、千粒重、籽粒数、开花期、成熟期、株高和营养生长期(NDVIvg)和灌浆期(NDVIllg)的归一化差异植被指数——中,株高具有最高的 PA(0.68),而籽粒产量则表现出中等水平的 PA(0.34)。结果表明,包含 G×E 互作的基因组选择模型在硬质小麦的正向预测和应用中具有很大的潜力,可以提高遗传增益。