Plant Genome. 2017 Jul;10(2). doi: 10.3835/plantgenome2016.12.0130.
Wheat ( L.) breeding programs test experimental lines in multiple locations over multiple years to get an accurate assessment of grain yield and yield stability. Selections in early generations of the breeding pipeline are based on information from only one or few locations and thus materials are advanced with little knowledge of the genotype × environment interaction (G × E) effects. Later, large trials are conducted in several locations to assess the performance of more advanced lines across environments. Genomic selection (GS) models that include G × E covariates allow us to borrow information not only from related materials, but also from historical and correlated environments to better predict performance within and across specific environments. We used reaction norm models with several cross-validation schemes to demonstrate the increased breeding efficiency of Kansas State University's hard red winter wheat breeding program. The GS reaction norm models line effect (L) + environment effect (E), L + E + genotype environment (G), and L + E + G + (G × E) effects) showed high accuracy values (>0.4) when predicting the yield performance in untested environments, sites or both. The GS model L + E + G + (G × E) presented the highest prediction ability ( = 0.54) when predicting yield in incomplete field trials for locations with a moderate number of lines. The difficulty of predicting future years (forward prediction) is indicated by the relatively low accuracy ( = 0.171) seen even when environments with 300+ lines were included.
小麦(L.)育种计划在多年的多个地点测试实验品系,以对谷物产量和产量稳定性进行准确评估。在育种管道的早期世代中进行选择时,仅基于来自一个或少数几个地点的信息,因此在基因型与环境互作(G × E)效应方面知之甚少。后来,在多个地点进行大型试验,以评估更先进品系在不同环境中的表现。包含 G × E 协变量的基因组选择(GS)模型使我们不仅可以从相关材料中获取信息,还可以从历史和相关环境中获取信息,从而更好地预测特定环境内和跨环境的表现。我们使用具有几种交叉验证方案的反应规范模型,展示了堪萨斯州立大学硬红冬小麦育种计划的更高育种效率。GS 反应规范模型线效(L)+环境效(E)、L + E + 基因型环境(G)和 L + E + G +(G × E)效应)在预测未经测试的环境、地点或两者的产量表现时,具有较高的准确度值(>0.4)。当预测具有中等数量品系的地点的不完全田间试验中的产量时,GS 模型 L + E + G +(G × E)表现出最高的预测能力(=0.54)。即使包括 300 多个环境,未来年份(前向预测)的预测难度也表现出相对较低的准确性(=0.171)。