School of Environmental Science, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Geography, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2018 Aug 8;13(8):e0200781. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0200781. eCollection 2018.
Global food security and agricultural land management represent two urgent and intimately related challenges that humans must face. We quantify the changes in the global agricultural land footprint if the world were to adhere to the dietary guidelines put forth by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), while accounting for the land use change incurred by import/export required to meet those guidelines. We analyze data at country, continental, and global levels. USDA guidelines are viewed as an improvement on the current land-intensive diet of the average American, but despite this our results show that global adherence to the guidelines would require 1 gigahectare of additional land-roughly the size of Canada-under current agricultural practice. The results also show a strong divide between Eastern and Western hemispheres, with many Western hemisphere countries showing net land sparing under a USDA guideline diet, while many Eastern hemisphere countries show net land use increase under a USDA guideline diet. We conclude that national dietary guidelines should be developed using not just health but also global land use and equity as criteria. Because global lands are a limited resource, national dietary guidelines also need to be coordinated internationally, in much the same way greenhouse gas emissions are increasingly coordinated.
全球粮食安全和农业土地管理是人类必须面对的两个紧迫而密切相关的挑战。我们量化了如果全球遵循美国农业部(USDA)提出的饮食指南,全球农业土地足迹将会发生的变化,同时考虑到为满足这些指南而产生的进出口所导致的土地利用变化。我们在国家、大陆和全球层面分析数据。尽管 USDA 指南被认为是对当前美国人土地密集型饮食的一种改进,但我们的研究结果表明,在当前的农业实践下,要实现全球范围内的饮食指南,将需要额外的 10 亿公顷土地——大约相当于加拿大的面积。研究结果还显示出东西半球之间的明显差异,许多西半球国家在 USDA 指南饮食下显示出净土地节约,而许多东半球国家在 USDA 指南饮食下显示出净土地使用增加。我们得出的结论是,制定国家饮食指南不仅应该以健康为标准,还应该以全球土地利用和公平为标准。由于全球土地是有限的资源,国家饮食指南也需要在国际上进行协调,就像温室气体排放越来越协调一样。