Medical Research Council Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, Cambridge, UK.
Department of Psychology, Mental Health Research and Treatment Center, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
Br J Clin Psychol. 2019 Mar;58(1):91-109. doi: 10.1111/bjc.12202. Epub 2018 Aug 21.
Depression, which is common following acquired brain injury (ABI), has been shown to predict cognitive impairment, rehabilitation outcome, and quality of life. Whilst many studies have examined links between depression and cognitive-affective processing in the non-ABI population, their applicability to this important clinical group, where cognitive difficulties can be marked, remains unknown. Here, we investigated biases in prospective cognition, which is known to be disrupted in (non-ABI) depression yet important for well-being.
Cross-sectional design with three groups (depressed ABI, non-depressed ABI, and non-ABI control participants). Continuous data were additionally analysed in correlation analyses.
Individuals with ABI varying in extent of self-reported depression and matched non-ABI control participants completed assessments of mood and prospective cognition (anticipating and imagining future events), alongside background tests of executive function and fluid intelligence.
Relative to non-depressed ABI and control participants, depressed ABI individuals demonstrated a reduced positive bias in prospective cognition: whereas non-depressed ABI and control participants generated more examples of likely or possible positive versus negative future events, there was no evidence for such a positive bias in depressed ABI participants. Non-depressed ABI and control participants also reported more vivid mental imagery for positive versus negative future scenarios, whereas such a pattern was not evident in depressed ABI participants. This pattern emerged despite background impairments in fluid intelligence and executive function associated with ABI.
These findings (1) elucidate depression-linked cognitive-affective processes following ABI, where cognitive difficulties are common, and (2) highlight psychological processes associated with depression that are common to ABI and non-ABI populations.
Clinical implications A relative negative bias in future-directed cognition is associated with depressed mood in individuals with chronic ABI. Such processes may contribute to the onset and maintenance of depression following ABI. These findings suggest it may be important to consider a role for prospective cognition in psychological interventions for depression following ABI. Limitations of the study The extent to which depressed mood following ABI is associated with biases in other cognitive domains remains unclear. Whether similar patterns would be observed in acute patients with more profound cognitive difficulties requires further investigation. Despite large effect sizes, our sample size is modest; these effects thus require replication in larger groups.
脑外伤(ABI)后常出现抑郁,抑郁已被证明可预测认知障碍、康复结果和生活质量。虽然许多研究已经检查了非 ABI 人群中抑郁与认知情感加工之间的联系,但它们对认知障碍明显的这一重要临床群体的适用性仍不清楚。在这里,我们研究了前瞻性认知偏差,已知这种偏差在(非 ABI)抑郁中受到干扰,但对幸福感很重要。
具有三组(抑郁 ABI、非抑郁 ABI 和非 ABI 对照组)的横断面设计。连续数据还进行了相关分析。
个体的 ABI 程度不同,自我报告的抑郁程度不同,以及匹配的非 ABI 对照组参与者完成了情绪和前瞻性认知(预期和想象未来事件)的评估,以及执行功能和流体智力的背景测试。
与非抑郁 ABI 和对照组参与者相比,抑郁 ABI 个体的前瞻性认知呈正性偏差降低:而非抑郁 ABI 和对照组参与者生成的可能或可能的正性未来事件比负性未来事件多,但在抑郁 ABI 参与者中没有这种正性偏差的证据。非抑郁 ABI 和对照组参与者也报告说,积极的未来情景的心理意象比消极的未来情景更生动,而在抑郁 ABI 参与者中则没有这种模式。尽管与 ABI 相关的流体智力和执行功能存在背景损伤,但仍出现了这种模式。
这些发现(1)阐明了 ABI 后与抑郁相关的认知情感过程,在这些过程中,认知障碍很常见,(2)强调了与 ABI 和非 ABI 人群共同的与抑郁相关的心理过程。
临床意义:慢性 ABI 个体中,未来指向性认知的相对负性偏差与抑郁情绪有关。这些过程可能有助于 ABI 后抑郁的发生和维持。这些发现表明,在 ABI 后抑郁的心理干预中,考虑前瞻性认知可能很重要。研究的局限性:ABI 后抑郁与其他认知领域的偏差之间的关联程度尚不清楚。在认知障碍更严重的急性患者中是否会观察到类似的模式,还需要进一步研究。尽管效应量较大,但我们的样本量较小;这些效应需要在更大的群体中进行复制。