Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, FL 33136, USA.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
Contrast Media Mol Imaging. 2018 Jul 30;2018:1729071. doi: 10.1155/2018/1729071. eCollection 2018.
Radiomic features extracted from diverse MRI modalities have been investigated regarding their predictive and/or prognostic value in a variety of cancers. With the aid of a 3D realistic digital MRI phantom of the brain, the aim of this study was to examine the impact of pulse sequence parameter selection on MRI-based textural parameters of the brain.
MR images of the employed digital phantom were realized with , a simulation package made for fast generation of image sequences based on the Bloch equations. Pulse sequences being investigated consisted of spin echo (SE), gradient echo (GRE), spoiled gradient echo (SP-GRE), inversion recovery spin echo (IR-SE), and inversion recovery gradient echo (IR-GRE). Twenty-nine radiomic textural features related, respectively, to gray-level intensity histograms (GLIH), cooccurrence matrices (GLCOM), zone size matrices (GLZSM), and neighborhood difference matrices (GLNDM) were evaluated for the obtained MR realizations, and differences were identified.
It was found that radiomic features vary considerably among images generated by the five different T1-weighted pulse sequences, and the deviations from those measured on the T1 map vary among features, from a few percent to over 100%. Radiomic features extracted from T1-weighted spin-echo images with TR varying from 360 ms to 620 ms and TE = 3.4 ms showed coefficients of variation (CV) up to 45%, while up to 70%, for T2-weighted spin-echo images with TE varying over the range 60-120 ms and TR = 6400 ms.
Variability of radiologic textural appearance on MR realizations with respect to the choice of pulse sequence and imaging parameters is feature-dependent and can be substantial. It calls for caution in employing MRI-derived radiomic features especially when pooling imaging data from multiple institutions with intention of correlating with clinical endpoints.
从多种 MRI 模式中提取的放射组学特征已在各种癌症中针对其预测和/或预后价值进行了研究。本研究借助大脑的 3D 逼真数字 MRI 体模,旨在检查脉冲序列参数选择对基于 MRI 的脑纹理参数的影响。
使用专门用于根据布洛赫方程快速生成图像序列的仿真软件包 对所使用的数字体模的 MR 图像进行了实现。所研究的脉冲序列包括自旋回波(SE)、梯度回波(GRE)、扰相梯度回波(SP-GRE)、反转恢复自旋回波(IR-SE)和反转恢复梯度回波(IR-GRE)。针对获得的 MR 实现,评估了分别与灰度强度直方图(GLIH)、共生矩阵(GLCOM)、区尺寸矩阵(GLZSM)和邻域差矩阵(GLNDM)相关的 29 个放射组学纹理特征,并确定了差异。
发现五种不同的 T1 加权脉冲序列生成的图像之间的放射组学特征差异很大,并且特征之间与 T1 图测量值的偏差差异很大,从百分之几到百分之几百不等。TR 从 360ms 到 620ms 且 TE=3.4ms 的 T1 加权自旋回波图像中提取的放射组学特征的变异系数(CV)高达 45%,而 TE 在 60-120ms 之间变化且 TR=6400ms 的 T2 加权自旋回波图像中高达 70%。
脉冲序列和成像参数选择对 MR 实现的放射学纹理外观的可变性取决于特征,且可能很大。这需要谨慎使用 MRI 衍生的放射组学特征,尤其是在打算将成像数据从多个机构汇总并与临床终点相关联时。