Department of Population Health Science and Policy, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New York.
Biostatistics Unit, Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute, Seattle, Washington.
Stat Med. 2018 Dec 30;37(30):4680-4694. doi: 10.1002/sim.7947. Epub 2018 Sep 12.
Exposure to environmental mixtures can exert wide-ranging effects on child neurodevelopment. However, there is a lack of statistical methods that can accommodate the complex exposure-response relationship between mixtures and neurodevelopment while simultaneously estimating neurodevelopmental trajectories. We introduce Bayesian varying coefficient kernel machine regression (BVCKMR), a hierarchical model that estimates how mixture exposures at a given time point are associated with health outcome trajectories. The BVCKMR flexibly captures the exposure-response relationship, incorporates prior knowledge, and accounts for potentially nonlinear and nonadditive effects of individual exposures. This model assesses the directionality and relative importance of a mixture component on health outcome trajectories and predicts health effects for unobserved exposure profiles. Using contour plots and cross-sectional plots, BVCKMR also provides information about interactions between complex mixture components. The BVCKMR is applied to a subset of data from PROGRESS, a prospective birth cohort study in Mexico city on exposure to metal mixtures and temporal changes in neurodevelopment. The mixture include metals such as manganese, arsenic, cobalt, chromium, cesium, copper, lead, cadmium, and antimony. Results from a subset of Programming Research in Obesity, Growth, Environment and Social Stressors data provide evidence of significant positive associations between second trimester exposure to copper and Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development cognition score at 24 months, and cognitive trajectories across 6-24 months. We also detect an interaction effect between second trimester copper and lead exposures for cognition at 24 months. In summary, BVCKMR provides a framework for estimating neurodevelopmental trajectories associated with exposure to complex mixtures.
暴露于环境混合物会对儿童神经发育产生广泛的影响。然而,目前缺乏能够适应混合物与神经发育之间复杂的暴露-反应关系,同时估计神经发育轨迹的统计方法。我们引入了贝叶斯变系数核机器回归(BVCKMR),这是一种层次模型,可以估计在给定时间点混合物暴露与健康结果轨迹之间的关系。BVCKMR 灵活地捕捉暴露-反应关系,纳入了先验知识,并考虑了个体暴露的潜在非线性和非加性效应。该模型评估了混合物成分对健康结果轨迹的方向和相对重要性,并预测了未观察到的暴露谱的健康影响。通过轮廓图和横截面图,BVCKMR 还提供了有关复杂混合物成分之间相互作用的信息。BVCKMR 应用于来自墨西哥城的前瞻性出生队列研究 PROGRESS 中金属混合物暴露和神经发育随时间变化的一部分数据。混合物包括锰、砷、钴、铬、铯、铜、铅、镉和锑等金属。 Programming Research in Obesity、Growth、Environment and Social Stressors 数据的一部分结果提供了证据,表明在妊娠中期暴露于铜与贝利婴幼儿发育认知评分在 24 个月时呈显著正相关,并且在 6-24 个月期间认知轨迹呈正相关。我们还检测到妊娠中期铜和铅暴露对 24 个月时认知的交互作用。总之,BVCKMR 为估计与复杂混合物暴露相关的神经发育轨迹提供了一个框架。