College of Veterinary Medicine, School of Veterinary and Life Sciences, Murdoch University, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
Department of Veterinary, Tibet Livestock Research Institute, Tibet Academy of Agriculture and Animal Science, Lhasa City, Tibet, China.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019 Jan;66(1):476-487. doi: 10.1111/tbed.13049. Epub 2018 Nov 20.
Brucellosis is considered as an endemic disease in yaks (Bos grunniens) in China, but few economic analyses describing the cost of the disease and potential benefits of control have been reported. The aim of the study was to estimate the economic cost of brucellosis in yaks and the economic value of three control strategies: (a) vaccination; (b) test-and-slaughter; and (c) a combination of vaccination and test-and-slaughter programs in Damxung and Maizhokunggar counties and Pali township of Yadong county in Tibet. Using data from a cross-sectional seroprevalence survey conducted in 2015, combined with financial data, the predicted costs and benefits of the different control strategies were simulated over a 6-year period. The annual estimated cost of brucellosis in yaks within the study area was US$ 521,043 (95% CI: US$ 334,441; US$ 759,862), with an annual average cost per yak estimated at US$ 1.42 (95% CI: US$ 0.91, US$ 2.07). The benefit-cost analysis predicted that vaccination was the most effective control method with a benefit-cost ratio (BCR) of 3.19 (95% CI: 2.17, 4.66) and a net present value (NPV) of US$ 313,355 (95% CI: US$ 157,679, US$ 541,062) over a 6-year period. A sensitivity analysis found the NPV was most sensitive to the loss from a female yak aborting in the vaccination control program. In contrast, the price of yaks that were slaughtered had the largest influence on the NPV for both the test-and-slaughter control program and the combination control program. These estimates provide valuable information and establish a foundation for formulating and implementing cost-effective measures for controlling the disease in yaks on the Tibetan plateau, and more broadly in China.
布鲁氏菌病被认为是中国牦牛(Bos grunniens)的地方性疾病,但很少有经济分析报告描述该病的成本和控制的潜在收益。本研究旨在估计牦牛布鲁氏菌病的经济成本,以及三种控制策略的经济价值:(a)疫苗接种;(b)检测和扑杀;(c)在西藏的当雄县、玛曲县和亚东县的帕里乡实施疫苗接种和检测扑杀相结合的方案。本研究使用了 2015 年进行的一项横断面血清流行率调查的数据,结合财务数据,对不同控制策略在 6 年内的成本和效益进行了模拟预测。研究区域内牦牛布鲁氏菌病的年估计成本为 521,043 美元(95%置信区间:334,441 美元;759,862 美元),每头牦牛的年平均成本估计为 1.42 美元(95%置信区间:0.91 美元;2.07 美元)。效益成本分析预测,疫苗接种是最有效的控制方法,效益成本比(BCR)为 3.19(95%置信区间:2.17,4.66),净现值(NPV)为 313,355 美元(95%置信区间:157,679 美元;541,062 美元),为期 6 年。敏感性分析发现,NPV 对疫苗接种控制方案中母牦牛流产造成的损失最敏感。相比之下,检测和扑杀控制方案以及联合控制方案中,被扑杀的牦牛价格对 NPV 的影响最大。这些估计为制定和实施在青藏高原和更广泛的中国控制牦牛疾病的具有成本效益的措施提供了有价值的信息和基础。