Gwin Jess A, Leidy Heather J
Department of Nutrition Science, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.
Curr Dev Nutr. 2018 Aug 28;2(11):nzy074. doi: 10.1093/cdn/nzy074. eCollection 2018 Nov.
Observational studies show associations between breakfast skipping, reduced satiety, and poor sleep quality; however, intervention studies are lacking.
The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of consuming breakfast compared with breakfast skipping on appetitive, hormonal, and neural markers of appetite and satiety; ad libitum food intake; and exploratory measures of sleep health in young adults.
Thirteen adults [aged 23.5 ± 0.9 y (mean ± SEMs); body mass index (kg/m): 23.6 ± 0.6] completed the following randomized crossover-design study. Participants consumed a high-protein breakfast ("Breakfast"; 340 kcal, 30 g protein, 36 g carbohydrate, 9 g fat) or skipped breakfast ("Skip") for 7 d/treatment. On day 7, an 8-h clinical testing day was completed including assessments of hunger, fullness, desire to eat, prospective food consumption (PFC), related hormones, food cue-stimulated functional magnetic resonance imaging brain scans, and ad libitum evening food intake. Sleep quantity and quality were assessed with 7-d actigraphy, 7-d sleep diaries, and sleep-related hormones.
Morning and daily hunger, desire to eat, PFC, and ghrelin decreased, whereas fullness increased after the Breakfast pattern compared with after the Skip pattern (all, < 0.05). No difference in peptide YY (PYY) concentrations were detected. Hippocampal, parahippocampal, and middle frontal gyrus activations were reduced after the Breakfast pattern compared with the Skip pattern (all, < 0.01). Although no differences in daily food intake were observed, the Breakfast pattern reduced evening intake of high-carbohydrate and high-fat foods ( < 0.05), whereas evening sugar intake tended to be reduced compared with the Skip pattern ( = 0.085). Although Breakfast led to shorter total sleep time (TST) compared with Skip ( < 0.05), no difference in sleep efficiency (TST/sleep period) was detected. Perceived sleep quality and sleep onset tended to improve after Breakfast compared with after Skip ( = 0.060 and = 0.07, respectively).
Breakfast consumption improved appetite, satiety, and diet quality and may support some aspects of sleep health in healthy young adults. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT03031132.
观察性研究表明不吃早餐、饱腹感降低与睡眠质量差之间存在关联;然而,缺乏干预性研究。
本研究的目的是比较吃早餐与不吃早餐对年轻成年人食欲、激素及饱腹感的神经标志物、随意食物摄入量以及睡眠健康探索性指标的影响。
13名成年人[年龄23.5±0.9岁(均值±标准误);体重指数(kg/m²):23.6±0.6]完成了以下随机交叉设计研究。参与者在每种处理下分别进行7天的高蛋白质早餐(“早餐组”;340千卡,30克蛋白质,36克碳水化合物,9克脂肪)或不吃早餐(“不吃早餐组”)。在第7天,完成一个8小时的临床测试日,包括对饥饿感、饱腹感、进食欲望、预期食物摄入量(PFC)、相关激素、食物线索刺激的功能磁共振成像脑部扫描以及晚上随意食物摄入量的评估。通过7天的活动记录仪、7天的睡眠日记以及与睡眠相关的激素来评估睡眠量和质量。
与不吃早餐组相比,早餐组的早晨和全天饥饿感、进食欲望、PFC以及胃饥饿素降低,而饱腹感增加(均P<0.05)。未检测到肽YY(PYY)浓度存在差异。与不吃早餐组相比,早餐组后海马体、海马旁回和额中回的激活减少(均P<0.01)。虽然未观察到每日食物摄入量存在差异,但早餐组减少了晚上高碳水化合物和高脂肪食物的摄入量(P<0.05),而与不吃早餐组相比,晚上糖的摄入量有减少趋势(P=0.085)。虽然与不吃早餐组相比,早餐组导致总睡眠时间(TST)缩短(P<0.05),但未检测到睡眠效率(TST/睡眠时间)存在差异。与不吃早餐组相比,早餐组后自我感觉的睡眠质量和入睡情况有改善趋势(分别为P=0.060和P=0.07)。
吃早餐改善了食欲、饱腹感和饮食质量,并且可能有助于健康年轻成年人睡眠健康的某些方面。本试验在clinicaltrials.gov上注册,注册号为NCT03031132。