Ascenso Sara, Perkins Rosie, Williamon Aaron
Centre for Performance Science, Royal College of Music, London, United Kingdom.
Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College, London, United Kingdom.
Front Psychol. 2018 Nov 6;9:1895. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01895. eCollection 2018.
While music has been linked with enhanced wellbeing across a wide variety of contexts, the professional pursuit of a music career is frequently associated with poor psychological health. Most research has focused on assessing negative functioning, and to date, few studies have attempted to profile musicians' wellbeing using a positive framework. This study aimed to generate a profile that represents indicators of optimal functioning among classical musicians. The PERMA model, which reconciles hedonic and eudaimonic wellbeing, was adopted and its five elements assessed with a sample of professional classical musicians: Positive Emotion, Engagement, Relationships, Meaning and Accomplishment. 601 participants (298 women, 303 men) engaged in careers as orchestral ( = 236), solo ( = 158), chamber ( = 112), and choral musicians ( = 36), as well as composers ( = 30) and conductors ( = 29), answered the PERMA-Profiler, a self-report questionnaire built to assess the five components of PERMA. Results point to high scores across all dimensions, with Meaning emerging as the highest rated dimension. Musicians scored significantly higher than general population indicators on Positive Emotion, Relationships and Meaning. When wellbeing is assessed as positive functioning and not the absence of illbeing, musicians show promising profiles. The reconciliation between these findings and the previous body of research pointing to the music profession as highly challenging for healthy psychological functioning is discussed.
虽然在各种背景下音乐都与幸福感增强有关,但从事音乐职业的专业追求却常常与心理健康不佳联系在一起。大多数研究都集中在评估负面功能上,迄今为止,很少有研究尝试用积极的框架来描述音乐家的幸福感。本研究旨在生成一个代表古典音乐家最佳功能指标的概况。采用了调和享乐主义和自我实现幸福感的PERMA模型,并用一组专业古典音乐家样本对其五个要素进行了评估:积极情绪、投入、人际关系、意义和成就。601名参与者(298名女性,303名男性)从事管弦乐(=236)、独奏(=158)、室内乐(=112)和合唱音乐家(=36)以及作曲家(=30)和指挥(=29)的职业,他们回答了PERMA概况调查问卷,这是一份为评估PERMA的五个组成部分而编制的自我报告问卷。结果显示所有维度得分都很高,其中意义维度得分最高。音乐家在积极情绪、人际关系和意义方面的得分显著高于一般人群指标。当将幸福感评估为积极功能而非没有不良状态时,音乐家展现出了良好的概况。本文讨论了这些发现与先前大量研究结果之间的矛盾,先前的研究表明音乐职业对心理健康功能具有高度挑战性。