Toxicity Assessment Division, National Health and Environmental Effects Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, US EPA, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27711.
Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education, Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830.
Toxicol Sci. 2018 Dec 1;166(2):394-408. doi: 10.1093/toxsci/kfy207.
Embryologic development involves cell differentiation and organization events that are unique to each tissue and organ and are susceptible to developmental toxicants. Animal models are the gold standard for identifying putative teratogens, but the limited throughput of developmental toxicological studies in animals coupled with the limited concordance between animal and human teratogenicity motivates a different approach. In vitro organoid models can mimic the three-dimensional (3D) morphogenesis of developing tissues and can thus be useful tools for studying developmental toxicology. Common themes during development like the involvement of epithelial-mesenchymal transition and tissue fusion present an opportunity to develop in vitro organoid models that capture key morphogenesis events that occur in the embryo. We previously described organoids composed of human stem and progenitor cells that recapitulated the cellular features of palate fusion, and here we further characterized the model by examining pharmacological inhibitors targeting known palatogenesis and epithelial morphogenesis pathways as well as 12 cleft palate teratogens identified from rodent models. Organoid survival was dependent on signaling through EGF, IGF, HGF, and FGF pathways, and organoid fusion was disrupted by inhibition of BMP signaling. We observed concordance between the effects of EGF, FGF, and BMP inhibitors on organoid fusion and epithelial cell migration in vitro, suggesting that organoid fusion is dependent on epithelial morphogenesis. Three of the 12 putative cleft palate teratogens studied here (theophylline, triamcinolone, and valproic acid) significantly disrupted in vitro organoid fusion, while tributyltin chloride and all-trans retinoic acid were cytotoxic to fusing organoids. The study herein demonstrates the utility of the in vitro fusion assay for identifying chemicals that disrupt human organoid morphogenesis in a scalable format amenable to toxicology screening.
胚胎发生发育涉及到细胞分化和组织器官特有的组织事件,易受发育毒物的影响。动物模型是识别潜在致畸物的金标准,但动物发育毒理学研究的通量有限,动物与人类致畸性的一致性有限,这促使我们采用不同的方法。体外类器官模型可以模拟发育组织的三维(3D)形态发生,因此可作为研究发育毒理学的有用工具。发育过程中的共同主题,如上皮-间充质转化和组织融合,为开发体外类器官模型提供了机会,这些模型可以捕捉胚胎中发生的关键形态发生事件。我们之前描述了由人干细胞和祖细胞组成的类器官,该类器官再现了腭裂融合的细胞特征,在这里,我们通过研究针对已知腭裂发生和上皮形态发生途径的药理学抑制剂以及从啮齿动物模型中鉴定出的 12 种腭裂致畸物进一步表征了该模型。类器官的存活依赖于 EGF、IGF、HGF 和 FGF 途径的信号传递,BMP 信号的抑制会破坏类器官的融合。我们观察到 EGF、FGF 和 BMP 抑制剂对类器官融合和上皮细胞体外迁移的影响之间存在一致性,表明类器官融合依赖于上皮形态发生。在研究的 12 种潜在腭裂致畸物中,有 3 种(茶碱、曲安奈德和丙戊酸)显著破坏了体外类器官融合,而三丁基锡氯化物和全反式视黄酸对融合类器官具有细胞毒性。本研究证明了体外融合测定法在可扩展格式中识别破坏人类类器官形态发生的化学物质的效用,该格式适合毒理学筛选。