Psychosocial Research Group, Lowy Research Centre, C25, Prince of Wales Clinical School, Faculty of Medicine, UNSW Sydney, Corner High and Botany St, Kensington, Sydney New South Wales, 2033, Australia.
Centre for Applied Nursing Research, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Western Sydney University, Ingham, Sydney, Australia.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2018 Dec 17;18(1):499. doi: 10.1186/s12884-018-2135-0.
Access to information about prenatal screening is important particularly in light of new techniques such as non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT). This study aimed to develop and examine the acceptability of a low literacy decision aid (DA) about Down syndrome screening among pregnant women with varying education levels and GPs.
We developed a DA booklet providing information about first-trimester combined testing, maternal serum screening, and NIPT. GPs and women participated in a telephone interview to examine the acceptability of the DA and measure screening knowledge before and after reading the DA. The knowledge measure was designed to assess whether women had understood the gist of the information presented in the decision aid. It comprised conceptual questions (e.g. screening tells you the chance of having a baby with Down syndrome) and numeric questions (e.g. the accuracy of different screening tests).
Twenty-nine women and 18 GPs participated. Regardless of education level, most women found the booklet 'very' clearly presented (n = 22, 76%), and 'very' informative (n = 23, 80%). Overall, women's conceptual and numeric knowledge improved after exposure to the DA, from 4% having adequate knowledge to 69%. Women's knowledge of NIPT also improved after receiving the decision aid, irrespective of education. Most GPs found it 'very' clearly presented (n = 13, 72%), and that it would 'very much' facilitate decision-making (n = 16, 89%).
The DA was found to be acceptable to women as well as GPs. A comprehensive evaluation of the efficacy of the decision aid compared to standard information is an important next step. Strategies are needed on how to implement the tool in practice.
获取有关产前筛查的信息很重要,尤其是考虑到新的技术,如非侵入性产前检测(NIPT)。本研究旨在开发并检验一种针对唐氏综合征筛查的低识字决策辅助工具(DA)在不同教育水平的孕妇和全科医生中的可接受性。
我们开发了一本 DA 手册,提供了关于早孕期联合检测、母体血清筛查和 NIPT 的信息。全科医生和妇女通过电话访谈参与了研究,以检验 DA 的可接受性,并在阅读 DA 前后测量筛查知识。该知识衡量旨在评估妇女是否理解了决策辅助工具中呈现的信息要点。它包括概念问题(例如,筛查告诉你怀有唐氏综合征婴儿的机会)和数值问题(例如,不同筛查测试的准确性)。
29 名妇女和 18 名全科医生参与了研究。无论教育水平如何,大多数妇女认为手册“非常”清晰易懂(n=22,76%),并且“非常”有信息(n=23,80%)。总的来说,妇女的概念和数值知识在接触 DA 后有所提高,从 4%的人有足够的知识提高到 69%。妇女对 NIPT 的知识在接受决策辅助后也有所提高,无论教育程度如何。大多数全科医生认为它“非常”清晰易懂(n=13,72%),并认为它将“非常”有助于决策(n=16,89%)。
该 DA 被发现对妇女和全科医生都可接受。下一步是对决策辅助工具与标准信息相比的效果进行全面评估。需要制定如何在实践中实施该工具的策略。