Public Health Policy Evaluation Unit, School of Public Health, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Department of Public Health & Policy, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
BMJ Open. 2019 Jan 28;9(1):e026966. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-026966.
To estimate the potential impacts of different Brexit trade policy scenarios on the price and intake of fruits and vegetables (F&V) and consequent cardiovascular disease (CVD) deaths in England between 2021 and 2030.
Economic and epidemiological modelling study with probabilistic sensitivity analysis.
The model combined publicly available data on F&V trade, published estimates of UK-specific price elasticities, national survey data on F&V intake, estimates on the relationship between F&V intake and CVD from published meta-analyses and CVD mortality projections for 2021-2030.
English adults aged 25 years and older.
We modelled four potential post-Brexit trade scenarios: (1) free trading agreement with the EU and maintaining half of non-EU free trade partners; (2) free trading agreement with the EU but no trade deal with any non-EU countries; (3) no-deal Brexit; and (4) liberalised trade regime that eliminates all import tariffs.
Cumulative coronary heart disease and stroke deaths attributed to the different Brexit scenarios modelled between 2021 and 2030.
Under all Brexit scenarios modelled, prices of F&V would increase, especially for those highly dependent on imports. This would decrease intake of F&V between 2.5% (95% uncertainty interval: 1.9% to 3.1%) and 11.4% (9.5% to 14.2%) under the different scenarios. Our model suggests that a no-deal Brexit scenario would be the most harmful, generating approximately 12 400 (6690 to 23 390) extra CVD deaths between 2021 and 2030, whereas establishing a free trading agreement with the EU would have a lower impact on mortality, contributing approximately 5740 (2860 to 11 910) extra CVD deaths.
Trade policy under all modelled Brexit scenarios could increase price and decrease intake of F&V, generating substantial additional CVD mortality in England. The UK government should consider the population health implications of Brexit trade policy options, including changes to food systems.
评估不同英国脱欧贸易政策情景对英格兰 2021 年至 2030 年水果和蔬菜(F&V)价格和摄入量的潜在影响,以及对随后心血管疾病(CVD)死亡的影响。
经济和流行病学模型研究,结合概率敏感性分析。
模型结合了 F&V 贸易的公开数据、英国特定价格弹性的已发表估算、国家 F&V 摄入量调查数据、已发表荟萃分析中 F&V 摄入量与 CVD 关系的估算以及 2021-2030 年 CVD 死亡率预测。
年龄在 25 岁及以上的英国成年人。
我们模拟了四种潜在的英国脱欧后贸易情景:(1)与欧盟达成自由贸易协定并维持一半的非欧盟自由贸易伙伴;(2)与欧盟达成自由贸易协定,但与任何非欧盟国家均无贸易协议;(3)无协议脱欧;(4)自由化贸易制度,取消所有进口关税。
在模拟的所有英国脱欧情景下,F&V 的价格都会上涨,尤其是那些高度依赖进口的产品。这将导致 2021 年至 2030 年期间 F&V 的摄入量减少 2.5%(95%置信区间:1.9%至 3.1%)至 11.4%(9.5%至 14.2%)。我们的模型表明,无协议脱欧情景最为不利,将在 2021 年至 2030 年期间额外产生约 12400 例(6690 至 23390 例)CVD 死亡,而与欧盟达成自由贸易协定对死亡率的影响较低,额外产生约 5740 例(2860 至 11910 例)CVD 死亡。
在所有模拟的英国脱欧情景下,贸易政策可能会提高 F&V 的价格并降低其摄入量,从而在英格兰产生大量额外的 CVD 死亡率。英国政府应考虑英国脱欧贸易政策选择对人口健康的影响,包括对食品系统的影响。