Burow Elke, Rostalski Anja, Harlizius Jürgen, Gangl Armin, Simoneit Céline, Grobbel Mirjam, Kollas Chris, Tenhagen Bernd-Alois, Käsbohrer Annemarie
German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment, Max-Dohrn-Str. 8-10, 10589, Berlin, Germany.
Bavarian Animal Health Services, Senator-Gerauer-Str. 23, 85586, Poing, Germany.
Prev Vet Med. 2019 Apr 1;165:52-62. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2019.02.008. Epub 2019 Feb 12.
The purpose of this longitudinal study was to describe the occurrence of antibiotic resistance in faecal Escherichia coli isolated from pigs between birth and slaughter and its association with antibiotic treatment. Four objectives were addressed: comparison of antibiotic resistance in isolates from a) treated vs. non-treated pigs, b) follow-up vs. initial samples of treated and non-treated pigs, c) pigs receiving treatments via different administration routes and d) sows and their piglets. Each comparison addressed the following antibiotic groups used for treatment: beta-lactams, tetracyclines, polymyxins and macrolides, and the susceptibility of E. coli isolates to the respective agents: ampicillin, tetracycline, colistin and azithromycin. Between 2014 and 2016, 406 focal animals from 29 commercial breeding herds were followed from birth to the end of the relevant fattening periods. All antibiotic treatments in these pigs were documented. Faecal samples were collected from the focal pigs once while suckling, once after weaning and three times during fattening, and from their dams once around farrowing. Escherichia coli isolated from these samples was tested for antibiotic susceptibility. In total, 264 animals from 19 breeding herds were treated with an antibiotic at least once during their lifetime. Beta-lactams, tetracyclines and colistin were used most frequently. Piglets were treated individually by injection (n = 108 treatments) or via drench (9); weaners via feed (192) or water (56) and fatteners via feed (30) or injection (15). Resistance to ampicillin and tetracycline in E. coli was already common prior to antibiotic treatment. Resistance proportions were higher for beta-lactam-, tetracycline-, colistin- and macrolide-treated pigs compared to untreated pigs at different sampling periods (p < 0.05; Fisher's exact test). In the logistic analysis, the difference was confirmed for beta-lactam-treated vs. untreated pigs. In E. coli from macrolide-untreated pigs, resistance to azithromycin was more frequent compared to pre-treatment values. Route of application did not affect rates of antibiotic resistance in the logistic analysis even though Fisher's exact test indicated associations for beta-lactams (feed/water vs. injection), tetracyclines (feed/water vs. non-treatment) and macrolides (tulathromycin-injection vs. tylosin in feed). Piglets were more likely to carry an E. coli resistant to ampicillin or azithromycin if their dams did so as well. Our results suggest further research on resistance effects by administration routes is required. Reducing antibiotic resistance in sows might lead to a lower level of beta-lactam or macrolide-resistant E. coli among their progeny. To preserve treatment options for bacterial infections, antibiotic use should be restricted to necessary cases.
这项纵向研究的目的是描述从出生到屠宰的猪粪便中分离出的大肠埃希菌的抗生素耐药性发生情况及其与抗生素治疗的关联。研究涉及四个目标:比较a) 经治疗与未经治疗的猪分离株中的抗生素耐药性;b) 经治疗和未经治疗的猪的随访样本与初始样本中的抗生素耐药性;c) 通过不同给药途径接受治疗的猪中的抗生素耐药性;d) 母猪及其仔猪中的抗生素耐药性。每次比较都涉及以下用于治疗的抗生素类别:β-内酰胺类、四环素类、多粘菌素类和大环内酯类,以及大肠埃希菌分离株对相应药物的敏感性:氨苄西林、四环素、黏菌素和阿奇霉素。2014年至2016年期间,对来自29个商业繁殖猪群的406头重点动物从出生到相关育肥期结束进行了跟踪。记录了这些猪的所有抗生素治疗情况。在重点猪哺乳时采集一次粪便样本,断奶后采集一次,育肥期间采集三次,在其母猪分娩前后采集一次。对从这些样本中分离出的大肠埃希菌进行抗生素敏感性测试。总共有来自19个繁殖猪群的264头动物在其一生中至少接受过一次抗生素治疗。β-内酰胺类、四环素类和黏菌素使用最为频繁。仔猪通过注射(n = 108次治疗)或灌服(9次)进行个体治疗;断奶仔猪通过饲料(192次)或饮水(56次)进行治疗,育肥猪通过饲料(30次)或注射(15次)进行治疗。在抗生素治疗之前,大肠埃希菌对氨苄西林和四环素的耐药性就已经很常见。在不同采样期,与未经治疗的猪相比,接受β-内酰胺类、四环素类、黏菌素类和大环内酯类治疗的猪的耐药比例更高(p < 0.05;Fisher精确检验)。在逻辑分析中,证实了接受β-内酰胺类治疗的猪与未经治疗的猪之间存在差异。在未经大环内酯类治疗的猪的大肠埃希菌中,与治疗前相比,对阿奇霉素的耐药性更常见。尽管Fisher精确检验表明β-内酰胺类(饲料/饮水与注射)、四环素类(饲料/饮水与未治疗)和大环内酯类(泰拉霉素注射与饲料中的泰乐菌素)存在关联,但给药途径在逻辑分析中并未影响抗生素耐药率。如果仔猪的母猪也携带对氨苄西林或阿奇霉素耐药的大肠埃希菌,那么这些仔猪更有可能携带这种耐药菌。我们的结果表明,需要进一步研究给药途径对抗药性的影响。降低母猪中的抗生素耐药性可能会导致其后代中β-内酰胺类或大环内酯类耐药大肠埃希菌的水平降低。为了保留细菌感染的治疗选择,抗生素的使用应仅限于必要情况。