Leggieri Melissa, Thaut Michael H, Fornazzari Luis, Schweizer Tom A, Barfett Joseph, Munoz David G, Fischer Corinne E
Keenan Research Centre for Biomedical Research, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Faculty of Medicine, Institute of Medical Science, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Front Neurosci. 2019 Mar 12;13:132. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2019.00132. eCollection 2019.
Music interventions have been widely adopted as a potential non-pharmacological therapy for patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) to treat cognitive and/or behavioral symptoms of the disease. In spite of the prevalence of such therapies, evidence for their effectiveness report mixed results in the literature. The purpose of this narrative review is to investigate the effectiveness of various intervention strategies (music therapy vs. music listening techniques) and music type used in the intervention (individualized vs. non-individualized music) on cognitive and behavioral outcomes for persons with AD. Databases were searched for studies using either active music therapy or music listening techniques over the last 10 years. These studies were in English, included persons with AD dementia, and whose protocol gathered pre- and post-intervention outcome measures. We initially identified 206 papers which were then reduced to 167 after removing duplicates. Further review yielded 13 papers which were extensively reviewed, resulting in a final sample of six papers. Our analysis of these papers suggested that, regardless of the music intervention approach, individualized music regimens provided the best outcomes for the patient. Furthermore, music listening may act as a relaxation technique and therefore provide a long-term impact for the patient, while active music therapy may acts to engage participants through social interaction and provide acute benefits. Our findings suggest that music techniques can be utilized in various ways to improve behavior and cognition.
音乐干预已被广泛用作治疗阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者认知和/或行为症状的一种潜在非药物疗法。尽管这类疗法很普遍,但文献中关于其有效性的证据报告结果不一。本叙述性综述的目的是研究各种干预策略(音乐疗法与音乐聆听技巧)以及干预中使用的音乐类型(个性化音乐与非个性化音乐)对AD患者认知和行为结果的有效性。检索数据库以查找过去10年中使用主动音乐疗法或音乐聆听技巧的研究。这些研究为英文,纳入了AD痴呆患者,且其方案收集了干预前后的结果测量数据。我们最初识别出206篇论文,去除重复项后减少至167篇。进一步审查得到13篇论文并进行了详细审查,最终样本为6篇论文。我们对这些论文的分析表明,无论采用何种音乐干预方法,个性化音乐方案对患者的效果最佳。此外,聆听音乐可能作为一种放松技巧,从而对患者产生长期影响,而主动音乐疗法可能通过社交互动促使参与者参与并带来即时益处。我们的研究结果表明,音乐技巧可通过多种方式用于改善行为和认知。