The permanent adhesive produced by adult barnacles is held together by tightly folded proteins that form amyloid-like materials distinct among marine foulants. In this work, we link stretches of alternating charged and noncharged linear sequences from a family of adhesive proteins to their role in forming fibrillar nanomaterials. Using recombinant proteins and short barnacle cement derived peptides (BCPs), we find a central sequence with charged motifs of the pattern [Gly/Ser/Val/Thr/Ala-X], where X are charged amino acids, to exert specific control over timing, structure, and morphology of fibril formation. While most BCPs remain dormant, the core segment demonstrates rapid polymerization as well as an ability to template other peptides with no propensity for self-assembly. Patterned charge domains assemble dormant peptides through a specific antiparallel β-sheet structure as measured by FTIR. While charged domains favor an antiparallel structure, BCPs without charged domains switch fibril assembly to favor simpler parallel β-sheet aggregates. In addition to activation, charged domains direct nanofibers to grow into discrete microns long fibrils similar to the natural adhesive, while segments without such domains only form short branched aggregates. The assembly of adhesive sequences through recognition of structured templates outlines a strategy used by barnacles to control physical mechanisms of underwater adhesive delivery, activation, and curing based on molecular recognition between proteins.