Sum Melissa, Zhu Tracy Y, Zhou Bin, Zhang Zhendong, Bilezikian John P, Guo X Edward, Qin Ling, Walker Marcella
Division of Endocrinology Department of Medicine New York University Langone Health Medical Center New York NY USA.
Bone Quality and Health Assessment Center of the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology the Chinese University of Hong Kong Hong Kong SAR PR China.
JBMR Plus. 2018 Nov 5;3(4):e10083. doi: 10.1002/jbm4.10083. eCollection 2019 Apr.
We cross-sectionally compared racial differences in bone quality between Chinese women in the United States (US) and Hong Kong (HK) with white women. A total of 514 women were included. We measured bone geometry, mass, microstructure, and stiffness by high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography (HR-pQCT), individual trabecula segmentation (ITS), and microfinite element analysis (μFEA). After adjustment for age and body mass index (BMI), premenopausal Chinese women in the US and HK had smaller bone area but greater radial cortical (Ct.) thickness and Ct. and trabecular (Tb.) volumetric bone mineral density (vBMD) versus white women but did not differ from each other. At the radius, Tb. number was lower and spacing greater in Chinese women from HK and the US versus white women, whereas Chinese women did not differ from each other. Tb. thickness was highest in Chinese women from HK, intermediate in Chinese-Americans, and lowest in white women. Chinese women had more trabecular plates versus white women, leading to greater age- and BMI-adjusted stiffness for premenopausal Chinese women in HK and the US (both < 0.05) versus white women. Tibial differences were similar in premenopausal women; analogous trends in microstructure were present in postmenopausal women at the tibia, although stiffness did not differ. In contrast, at the radius, cortical, plate-to-rod ratio, and stiffness were similar between postmenopausal HK and white women. Adjusting for age, weight, and height rather than age and BMI tended to reduce differences in bone size and Tb. parameters but accentuate cortical differences such that Chinese premenopausal women in both locations and postmenopausal women from HK had higher stiffness at both skeletal sites compared with white women. Compared with white women, Chinese women in the US and HK have vBMD and microstructural advantages leading to higher or similar mechanical competence in pre- and postmenopausal women, respectively, despite smaller bone size.
我们对美国和中国香港的华裔女性与白人女性的骨质量种族差异进行了横断面比较。共纳入514名女性。我们通过高分辨率外周定量计算机断层扫描(HR-pQCT)、个体小梁分割(ITS)和微有限元分析(μFEA)测量了骨几何结构、骨量、微观结构和骨硬度。在对年龄和体重指数(BMI)进行调整后,美国和中国香港的绝经前华裔女性的骨面积较小,但与白人女性相比,桡骨皮质(Ct.)厚度、Ct.和小梁(Tb.)体积骨密度(vBMD)更高,但她们之间没有差异。在桡骨处,中国香港和美国的华裔女性的Tb.数量低于白人女性,间距大于白人女性,而华裔女性之间没有差异。中国香港的华裔女性的Tb.厚度最高,华裔美国人居中,白人女性最低。与白人女性相比,华裔女性的小梁板更多,导致中国香港和美国绝经前华裔女性经年龄和BMI调整后的骨硬度更高(均P<0.05)。绝经前女性的胫骨差异相似;绝经后女性胫骨的微观结构也有类似趋势,尽管骨硬度没有差异。相比之下,在桡骨处,中国香港绝经后女性和白人女性的皮质、板杆比和骨硬度相似。调整年龄、体重和身高而非年龄和BMI往往会减少骨大小和Tb.参数的差异,但会突出皮质差异,使得两个地区的绝经前华裔女性和中国香港的绝经后女性在两个骨骼部位的骨硬度均高于白人女性。与白人女性相比,美国和中国香港的华裔女性具有vBMD和微观结构优势,分别导致绝经前和绝经后女性具有更高或相似的机械性能,尽管骨大小较小。