Marzougui Afef, Ma Yu, Zhang Chongyuan, McGee Rebecca J, Coyne Clarice J, Main Dorrie, Sankaran Sindhuja
Department of Biological Systems Engineering, Washington State University, Pullman, WA, United States.
Department of Horticulture, Washington State University, Pullman, WA, United States.
Front Plant Sci. 2019 Apr 16;10:383. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2019.00383. eCollection 2019.
Aphanomyces root rot (ARR) is a soil-borne disease that results in severe yield losses in lentil. The development of resistant cultivars is one of the key strategies to control this pathogen. However, the evaluation of disease severity is limited to visual scores that can be subjective. This study utilized image-based phenotyping approaches to evaluate resistance in lentil genotypes in greenhouse (351 genotypes from lentil single plant/LSP derived collection and 191 genotypes from recombinant inbred lines/RIL using digital Red-Green-Blue/RGB and hyperspectral imaging) and field (173 RIL genotypes using unmanned aerial system-based multispectral imaging) conditions. Moderate to strong correlations were observed between RGB, multispectral, and hyperspectral derived features extracted from lentil shoots/roots and visual scores. In general, root features extracted from RGB imaging were found to be strongly associated with disease severity. With only three root traits, elastic net regression model was able to predict disease severity across and within multiple datasets ( = 0.45-0.73 and RMSE = 0.66-1.00). The selected features could represent visual disease scores. Moreover, we developed twelve normalized difference spectral indices (NDSIs) that were significantly correlated with disease scores: two NDSIs for lentil shoot section - computed from wavelengths of 1170, 1160, 1270, and 1280 nm (0.12 ≤ || ≤ 0.24, < 0.05) and ten NDSIs for lentil root sections - computed from wavelengths in the range of 630-670, 700-840, and 1320-1530 nm (0.10 ≤ || ≤ 0.50, < 0.05). Root-derived NDSIs were more accurate in predicting disease scores with an of 0.54 (RMSE = 0.86), especially when the model was trained and tested on LSP accessions, compared to of 0.25 (RMSE = 1.64) when LSP and RIL genotypes were used as train and test datasets, respectively. Importantly, NDSIs - computed from wavelengths of 700, 710, 730, and 790 nm - had strong positive correlations with disease scores (0.35 ≤ ≤ 0.50, < 0.0001), which was confirmed in field phenotyping with similar correlations using vegetation index with red edge wavelength (normalized difference red edge, 0.36 ≤ || ≤ 0.57, < 0.0001). The adopted image-based phenotyping approaches can help plant breeders to objectively quantify ARR resistance and reduce the subjectivity in selecting potential genotypes.
腐皮镰孢根腐病(ARR)是一种土传病害,会导致小扁豆严重减产。培育抗病品种是控制这种病原菌的关键策略之一。然而,病害严重程度的评估仅限于主观的视觉评分。本研究利用基于图像的表型分析方法,在温室条件下(来自小扁豆单株/LSP衍生群体的351个基因型和来自重组自交系/RIL的191个基因型,使用数字红-绿-蓝/RGB和高光谱成像)和田间条件下(使用基于无人机系统的多光谱成像的173个RIL基因型)评估小扁豆基因型的抗性。从小扁豆地上部/根部提取的RGB、多光谱和高光谱特征与视觉评分之间存在中度到强的相关性。一般来说,从RGB成像中提取的根部特征与病害严重程度密切相关。仅用三个根部性状,弹性网络回归模型就能预测多个数据集内和数据集间的病害严重程度((R^2 = 0.45 - 0.73),均方根误差RMSE = 0.66 - 1.00)。所选特征可以代表视觉病害评分。此外,我们开发了12个归一化差异光谱指数(NDSIs),它们与病害评分显著相关:两个用于小扁豆地上部切片的NDSIs——根据1170、1160、1270和1280 nm波长计算((0.12 ≤ |r| ≤ 0.24),(P < 0.05)),以及十个用于小扁豆根部切片的NDSIs——根据630 - 670、700 - 840和1320 - 1530 nm范围内的波长计算((0.10 ≤ |r| ≤ 0.50),(P < 0.05))。根部衍生的NDSIs在预测病害评分方面更准确,(R^2)为0.54(RMSE = 0.86),特别是当模型在LSP种质上进行训练和测试时,而当分别使用LSP和RIL基因型作为训练和测试数据集时,(R^2)为0.25(RMSE = 1.64)。重要的是,根据700、710、730和790 nm波长计算的NDSIs与病害评分有很强的正相关性((0.35 ≤ r ≤ 0.50),(P < 0.0001)),这在田间表型分析中使用具有红边波长的植被指数(归一化差异红边,(0.36 ≤ |r| ≤ 0.57),(P < 0.0001))得到了类似相关性的证实。所采用的基于图像的表型分析方法可以帮助植物育种者客观地量化ARR抗性,并减少选择潜在基因型时的主观性。