Bobon D P, Fanielle J, Mormont C, Breulet M, Bobon J
Acta Psychiatr Belg. 1978 Jul-Aug;78(4):619-34.
Eighteen inpatients suffering from a severe anxiety received in double-blind and crossover conditions iv and im injections of 10 mg diazepam, 5 mg lorazepam or saline t.i.d. during 5 days. The morning injections was made iv in a CCTV studio. Before injection and 20 mn after it, the patient filled out a 100 mm Visual Analogue Scale; his doctor-in-charge proceeded to a standard interview and to physiological measurements (tremor of hand, patellar reflexes, blood pressure, pulse rate). The videotaped interviews were randomly, i.e. time-blind, rated by two independent observers on 3 scales: the VAS, the Hamilton Anxiety Scale and an ad hoc Verbal and Non-Verbal Anxiety Scale (VNVA). The statistical analysis was completed by a logical analysis according to Lewis Carroll. The results demonstrate the superiority of lorazepam over diazepam on psychic anxiety, somatic anxiety, sleep and blood pressure, the only significant side-effect being drowsiness.
18名患有严重焦虑症的住院患者在双盲和交叉条件下,连续5天每天接受3次静脉注射和肌肉注射10毫克地西泮、5毫克劳拉西泮或生理盐水。早晨的注射在一个闭路电视演播室进行静脉注射。注射前及注射后20分钟,患者填写100毫米视觉模拟量表;其主治医生进行标准访谈并进行生理测量(手部震颤、髌反射、血压、脉搏率)。录像访谈由两名独立观察者随机(即时间盲法)按照3种量表进行评分:视觉模拟量表、汉密尔顿焦虑量表和一个专门的言语和非言语焦虑量表(VNVA)。根据刘易斯·卡罗尔的方法进行逻辑分析完成统计分析。结果表明,劳拉西泮在精神焦虑、躯体焦虑、睡眠和血压方面优于地西泮,唯一显著的副作用是嗜睡。