Clinical Instructor, Division of Hospital Medicine, Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, University of California, San Francisco.
Fellow, Department of Medicine, VA Puget Sound Health Care System and University of Washington.
MedEdPORTAL. 2021 May 19;17:11159. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.11159.
Current approaches to teaching diagnostic reasoning minimally address the need for deliberate practice. We developed an educational conference for internal medicine residents to practice diagnostic reasoning and examine how biases affect their differential diagnoses through cognitive autopsies.
We formatted the Virtual Interactive Case-Based Education (VICE) conference as a clinical problem-solving exercise, in which a facilitator presents a case to a single discussant selected from the audience. We delivered VICE on an internet-based conferencing platform with screen-sharing capability over approximately 30 minutes. To maximize learners' psychological safety, we employed an active facilitation model that normalized uncertainty and prioritized the diagnostic process over arriving at the correct diagnosis.
Resident attitudes toward VICE were assessed by utilizing a postconference survey and gathering descriptive data for 11 sessions. Ninety-seven percent of respondents ( = 35) felt that VICE was a novel and valuable addition to their curriculum. Qualitative data suggested that positive features of the conference included the opportunity to practice diagnostic reasoning, the single-discussant format, and the supportive learning environment. Discussants reported that holding the conference in person would have negatively impacted their experience.
Internal medicine residents universally valued the opportunity to engage in deliberate practice of case-based reasoning in a psychologically safe environment during the VICE conference. The virtual nature of the conference contributed significantly to discussants' positive experience. This resource includes all materials necessary to implement VICE, as well as an instructional video on facilitation.
目前的诊断推理教学方法很少能满足刻意练习的需求。我们为内科住院医师开发了一个教育会议,以练习诊断推理,并通过认知尸检检查偏见如何影响他们的鉴别诊断。
我们将虚拟互动基于案例的教育(VICE)会议设计为一种临床解决问题的练习,其中主持人向从观众中选出的一名讨论者介绍一个病例。我们通过具有屏幕共享功能的基于互联网的会议平台在大约 30 分钟内提供 VICE。为了最大限度地提高学习者的心理安全感,我们采用了积极的促进模式,该模式将不确定性正常化,并将诊断过程置于正确诊断之上。
通过在会议后进行调查并为 11 次会议收集描述性数据,评估了住院医师对 VICE 的态度。97%的受访者(=35)认为 VICE 是他们课程的新颖而有价值的补充。定性数据表明,会议的积极特点包括有机会练习诊断推理、单一讨论者格式和支持性的学习环境。讨论者报告说,如果在现场举行会议,他们的体验将会受到负面影响。
内科住院医师普遍重视在 VICE 会议中在心理安全的环境中进行基于案例的推理的刻意练习的机会。会议的虚拟性质极大地促进了讨论者的积极体验。该资源包括实施 VICE 所需的所有材料,以及关于促进的教学视频。