School of Health Sciences, Graduate Program in Dentistry, Universidade Positivo, Curitiba, PR, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2019 Jul 1;14(7):e0219183. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0219183. eCollection 2019.
The influence of curing mode and shade of resin cements on the color stability of minimum-thickness ceramic veneers after a three-year storage time in distilled water was evaluated in this study. Ninety-six 0.5-mm-thick feldspathic ceramic veneers (Mark II) were luted onto resin composite substrates (Filtek Z350 XT, shade A2E) with two light-cured (NX3 Light-cure and AllCem Veneer) and dual-cured resin cements (NX3 dual-cure and AllCem) in various shades. The specimens were stored in distilled water at 37°C. Color measurements were performed with a spectrophotometer at the following times: 1h and 24h; 7, 30, and 180 days; and 1, 2, and 3 years. Data for color difference (ΔEab) light-cured and dual-cured resin cements were analyzed by two-way ANOVA with repeated measures and Tukey's test (α = 0.05). For the light-cured cements, the ΔEab values were as follows: NX3-Yellow (2.37±1.35) = ACV-A1 (2.40±1.21) = ACV-Trans (2.52±1.46) = ACV-E-Bleach M (2.56±1.42) = NX3-White (2.69±1.49) = NX3-Clear (2.98±1.68). The lowest ΔE values were found for 1 h (0.61±0.36)a, followed by 24 h (1.15±0.55)b and 30 days (2.48±1.11)c. One year, 180 days, and 2 and 3 years presented higher ΔEab values (3.34±0.94, 3.52±1.04, 3.52±0.95 and 3.55±1.14, respectively)d. For the dual-cured cements, the ΔEab values varied as follows: NX3-Clear (2.32±1.24)a = NX3-Yellow (2.37±1.32)a = NX3-White (2.76±1.43)a < AC-Trans (3.77±1.91)b = AC-A3 (4.13±2.11)b < AC-A1 (5.38±2.92)c. Considering time, the lowest ΔEab values were found for 1 h (0.48±0.25)a, followed by 24 h (2.13 ±0.83)b, 30 days (3.54±1.31)c, and 180 days (3,70±1.73)c. The follow-up times of 1 (4.43±2.15)d, 2 (5.02±1.74)e, and 3 years (4.90±2.12)e presented higher ΔEab values. This study demonstrated that light-cured resin cements were less susceptible to color change than dual-cured cements. After 2 years of follow-up, all cements presented ΔEab values above the acceptability threshold.
本研究旨在评估水存储 3 年后不同光照固化及颜色深浅的树脂水门汀对最低厚度陶瓷贴面颜色稳定性的影响。96 个 0.5mm 厚的长石质陶瓷贴面(Mark II)被用两种光照固化树脂水门汀(NX3 Light-cure 和 AllCem Veneer)和两种双重固化树脂水门汀(NX3 dual-cure 和 AllCem)黏结在树脂复合材料基底(Filtek Z350 XT,A2E 色)上。将样本储存在 37°C 的蒸馏水中。在以下时间点使用分光光度计进行颜色测量:1h 和 24h;7、30 和 180 天;1、2 和 3 年。采用重复测量的双因素方差分析和 Tukey 检验(α=0.05)对光固化和双重固化树脂水门汀的颜色差异(ΔEab)数据进行分析。对于光固化水门汀,ΔEab 值如下:NX3-Yellow(2.37±1.35)=ACV-A1(2.40±1.21)=ACV-Trans(2.52±1.46)=ACV-E-Bleach M(2.56±1.42)=NX3-White(2.69±1.49)=NX3-Clear(2.98±1.68)。最低的ΔE 值在 1h(0.61±0.36)a 时发现,其次是 24h(1.15±0.55)b 和 30 天(2.48±1.11)c。1 年、180 天和 2 年、3 年的ΔEab 值更高(3.34±0.94、3.52±1.04、3.52±0.95 和 3.55±1.14,d)。对于双重固化水门汀,ΔEab 值如下:NX3-Clear(2.32±1.24)a=NX3-Yellow(2.37±1.32)a=NX3-White(2.76±1.43)a<AC-Trans(3.77±1.91)b=AC-A3(4.13±2.11)b<AC-A1(5.38±2.92)c。考虑时间因素,最低的ΔEab 值在 1h(0.48±0.25)a 时发现,其次是 24h(2.13 ±0.83)b、30 天(3.54±1.31)c 和 180 天(3.70±1.73)c。1 年(4.43±2.15)d、2 年(5.02±1.74)e 和 3 年(4.90±2.12)e 的随访时间有更高的ΔEab 值。本研究表明,光固化树脂水门汀比双重固化树脂水门汀不易发生颜色变化。2 年随访后,所有水门汀的ΔEab 值均超过可接受阈值。