School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Environmental and Life Sciences, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Patient Educ Couns. 2020 Feb;103(2):245-253. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2019.08.031. Epub 2019 Aug 24.
Explore how partners are involved in treatment-related decision-making within triadic clinical encounters.
Studies were identified via database searches and reference lists. One author assessed eligibility of studies, which were verified by an additional co-author. Data were extracted by one author and cross-checked for accuracy by a second. Quality of articles was assessed using Qualsyst. Retrieved studies were categorised by one author, and agreed through discussion.
From 2442 records, 14 studies were included and categorised as: (1) Descriptions of partner role and behaviour; (2) Role intentions of partners; (3) Relationship between partner and patient behaviour; (4) HCP-Partner interactions.
Partners are often involved in triadic clinical consultations that have implications for treatment-related decision making. Most studies offered general descriptions but lacked detailed investigation of communicative processes in triads and how these may operate with partners vs. other companions.
Existing studies lack detailed investigation through direct observation of the processes of partner involvement. Research in other areas of clinical communication suggests that future interventions could be informed by attention to the following areas: partner behaviour vs. other companion types in triads; relationships between partner involvement and decision-making processes; partner involvement in triads vs. other groups (e.g. quadratic).
探讨在三方临床访谈中,伴侣如何参与与治疗相关的决策。
通过数据库搜索和参考文献列表确定研究。一位作者评估研究的合格性,由另一位合著者进行验证。一位作者提取数据,并由第二位作者交叉检查准确性。使用 Qualsyst 评估文章的质量。一位作者对检索到的研究进行分类,并通过讨论达成一致。
从 2442 条记录中,纳入了 14 项研究,并分为:(1)描述伴侣的角色和行为;(2)伴侣的角色意图;(3)伴侣与患者行为之间的关系;(4)卫生保健提供者-伴侣互动。
伴侣通常参与三方临床咨询,这对与治疗相关的决策有影响。大多数研究仅提供了一般描述,但缺乏对三方沟通过程的详细调查,以及这些过程如何在伴侣与其他同伴之间运作。
现有研究缺乏通过直接观察伴侣参与过程的详细调查。临床沟通其他领域的研究表明,未来的干预措施可以从以下方面得到启示:三方中伴侣行为与其他同伴类型的比较;伴侣参与度与决策过程之间的关系;三方中伴侣的参与与其他群体(例如二次群体)的参与。