Giraudeau Caroline, Bailly Nathalie
Laboratoire Psychologie des Ages de la Vie et Adaptation (PAVeA), Université de Tours, 3, rue des tanneurs, B.P.4103, 37041 Tours Cedex 1, France.
Eur J Ageing. 2019 Jan 28;16(3):363-376. doi: 10.1007/s10433-018-00497-4. eCollection 2019 Sep.
Over the past 40 years, there has been a growing trend for intergenerational initiatives worldwide. Intergenerational programs (IGPs) aim to facilitate cooperation and exchange among different age groups. While most studies highlight the benefits for each generation, the programs and study designs vary widely. We conducted a systematic review of the scientific literature between 2005 and 2015 to: (1) characterize and define the IGPs studied and (2) identify the benefits for school-age children and older people aged 60 years or over. First, 53 articles with defined keywords were collected from online databases. Then, using inclusion and exclusion criteria, 11 articles were selected. These were classified according to methodological quality and were analyzed one by one. The content of the programs varied: three involved artistic activities, three educational activities, one health, three open-ended activities, and one was organized around a citizen's project. Concerning the benefits of IGPs for children and older adults, some studies highlighted significant differences in positive attitudes, behaviors, confidence, and competence for the children, and significant differences in mental and physical health, and quality of life for older adults. However, it should be noted that those benefits are not systematic. Our findings are discussed in the light of the meaningfulness of the activities and the role of IGPs, organization of the program, and participants' knowledge of the other generation. Future studies may wish to consider searching for additional variables to further refine our understanding of the benefits for participants.
在过去40年里,全球范围内代际倡议的趋势不断增强。代际项目(IGPs)旨在促进不同年龄组之间的合作与交流。虽然大多数研究强调了对每一代人的益处,但这些项目和研究设计差异很大。我们对2005年至2015年期间的科学文献进行了系统综述,目的是:(1)描述和定义所研究的代际项目;(2)确定对学龄儿童和60岁及以上老年人的益处。首先,从在线数据库中收集了53篇带有特定关键词的文章。然后,根据纳入和排除标准,挑选出11篇文章。这些文章根据方法学质量进行分类,并逐一进行分析。项目内容各不相同:三个涉及艺术活动,三个涉及教育活动,一个涉及健康,三个是开放式活动,还有一个是围绕公民项目组织的。关于代际项目对儿童和老年人的益处,一些研究强调了儿童在积极态度、行为、信心和能力方面的显著差异,以及老年人在身心健康和生活质量方面的显著差异。然而,应该指出的是,这些益处并非是系统性的。我们根据活动的意义、代际项目的作用、项目的组织以及参与者对另一代人的了解来讨论我们的研究结果。未来的研究不妨考虑寻找其他变量,以进一步完善我们对参与者益处的理解。