与患者合作进行质量改进:是否为医疗保健组织管理者带来了新的实践?
Partnering with patients in quality improvement: towards renewed practices for healthcare organization managers?
机构信息
Department of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, School of Public Health, University of Montreal, Montreal, Canada.
Department of Management, HEC Montreal, Montreal, Canada.
出版信息
BMC Health Serv Res. 2019 Nov 8;19(1):815. doi: 10.1186/s12913-019-4618-8.
BACKGROUND
Around the world, many healthcare organizations engage patients as a quality improvement strategy. In Canada, the University of Montreal has developed a model which consists in partnering with patient advisors, providers, and managers in quality improvement. This model was introduced through its Partners in Care Programs tested with several quality improvement teams in Quebec, Canada. Partnering with patients in quality improvement brings about new challenges for healthcare managers. This model is recent, and little is known about how managers contribute to implementing and sustaining it using key practices.
METHODS
In-depth multi-level case studies were conducted within two healthcare organizations which have implemented a Partners in Care Program in quality improvement. The longitudinal design of this research enabled us to monitor the implementation of patient partnership initiatives from 2015 to 2017. In total, 38 interviews were carried out with managers at different levels (top-level, mid-level, and front-line) involved in the implementation of Partners in Care Programs. Additionally, seven focus groups were conducted with patients and providers.
RESULTS
Our findings show that managers are engaged in four main types of practices: 1-designing the patient partnership approach so that it makes sense to the entire organization; 2-structuring patient partnership to support its deployment and sustainability; 3-managing patient advisor integration in quality improvement to avoid tokenistic involvement; 4-evaluating patient advisor integration to support continuous improvement. Designing and structuring patient partnership are based on typical management practices used to implement change initiatives in healthcare organizations, whereas managing and evaluating patient advisor integration require new daily practices from managers. Our results reveal that managers at all levels, from top to front-line, are concerned with the implementation of patient partnership in quality improvement.
CONCLUSION
This research adds empirical support to the evidence regarding daily managerial practices used for implementing patient partnership initiatives in quality improvement and contributes to guiding healthcare organizations and managers when integrating such approaches.
背景
在全球范围内,许多医疗保健组织都将患者作为一种质量改进策略。在加拿大,蒙特利尔大学开发了一种模式,即与患者顾问、提供者和管理人员合作进行质量改进。该模式通过其在加拿大魁北克的几个质量改进团队中测试的合作伙伴护理计划引入。在质量改进中与患者合作带来了医疗保健经理的新挑战。这种模式是新的,对于管理者如何通过关键实践来促进和维持这种模式知之甚少。
方法
在两家已经实施合作伙伴护理计划以进行质量改进的医疗保健组织中进行了深入的多层次案例研究。这项研究的纵向设计使我们能够从 2015 年到 2017 年监测患者伙伴关系计划的实施情况。共有 38 名不同级别(高层、中层和一线)的管理人员参与了合作伙伴护理计划的实施,对其进行了访谈。此外,还与患者和提供者进行了七次焦点小组讨论。
结果
我们的研究结果表明,管理者从事四种主要类型的实践:1.设计患者伙伴关系方法,使其对整个组织有意义;2.构建患者伙伴关系以支持其部署和可持续性;3.管理患者顾问在质量改进中的整合,以避免象征性参与;4.评估患者顾问的整合,以支持持续改进。设计和构建患者伙伴关系是基于在医疗保健组织中实施变革计划的典型管理实践,而管理和评估患者顾问的整合需要管理者日常的新实践。我们的研究结果表明,从高层到一线的各级管理人员都关注质量改进中的患者伙伴关系的实施。
结论
这项研究为有关在质量改进中实施患者伙伴关系计划的日常管理实践的证据提供了经验支持,并有助于指导医疗保健组织和管理者在整合这些方法时。