Lim France, Chemin Fontaine de Fanny, 24300 Nontron, France.
CWD-Vetlab, Ecole Nationale Vétérinaire d'Alfort, F-94700 Maisons-Alfort, France.
Sensors (Basel). 2020 Jan 17;20(2):518. doi: 10.3390/s20020518.
With the emergence of numerical sensors in sports, there is an increasing need for tools and methods to compute objective motion parameters with great accuracy. In particular, inertial measurement units are increasingly used in the clinical domain or the sports one to estimate spatiotemporal parameters. The purpose of the present study was to develop a model that can be included in a smart device in order to estimate the horse speed per stride from accelerometric and gyroscopic data without the use of a global positioning system, enabling the use of such a tool in both indoor and outdoor conditions. The accuracy of two speed calculation methods was compared: one signal based and one machine learning model. Those two methods allowed the calculation of speed from accelerometric and gyroscopic data without any other external input. For this purpose, data were collected under various speeds on straight lines and curved paths. Two reference systems were used to measure the speed in order to have a reference speed value to compare each tested model and estimate their accuracy. Those models were compared according to three different criteria: the percentage of error above 0.6 m/s, the RMSE, and the Bland and Altman limit of agreement. The machine learning method outperformed its competitor by giving the lowest value for all three criteria. The main contribution of this work is that it is the first method that gives an accurate speed per stride for horses without being coupled with a global positioning system or a magnetometer. No similar study performed on horses exists to compare our work with, so the presented model is compared to existing models for human walking. Moreover, this tool can be extended to other equestrian sports, as well as bipedal locomotion as long as consistent data are provided to train the machine learning model. The machine learning model's accurate results can be explained by the large database built to train the model and the innovative way of slicing stride data before using them as an input for the model.
随着运动中数字传感器的出现,人们越来越需要使用工具和方法来计算具有高精度的客观运动参数。特别是,惯性测量单元在临床或运动领域越来越多地用于估计时空参数。本研究的目的是开发一种模型,可以将其包含在智能设备中,以便根据加速度计和陀螺仪数据估算每步的马的速度,而无需使用全球定位系统,从而可以在室内和室外条件下使用这种工具。比较了两种速度计算方法的准确性:一种基于信号的方法和一种机器学习模型。这两种方法都允许根据加速度计和陀螺仪数据计算速度,而无需任何其他外部输入。为此,在直线和曲线路径上以不同的速度收集了数据。使用了两种参考系统来测量速度,以便有参考速度值来比较每个测试模型并估计其准确性。根据三个不同的标准比较了这些模型:误差超过 0.6 m/s 的百分比、RMSE 和 Bland 和 Altman 一致性限。机器学习方法在所有三个标准下的表现都优于其竞争对手,给出的误差最小。这项工作的主要贡献在于,这是第一个无需与全球定位系统或磁力计耦合即可为马提供准确每步速度的方法。没有针对马的类似研究可以与我们的工作进行比较,因此将提出的模型与现有的人类步行模型进行了比较。此外,只要为机器学习模型提供一致的数据来训练模型,该工具就可以扩展到其他马术运动以及双足运动。机器学习模型准确的结果可以通过构建大型数据库来训练模型以及在将步数据作为模型输入之前对其进行切片的创新方法来解释。