University of California, Davis, CA, United States America.
PLoS One. 2020 Apr 2;15(4):e0230609. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230609. eCollection 2020.
Health, the environment, and animal rights represent the three main reasons people cite for vegetarian diet in Western societies. However, it has not been shown that these motives can be distinguished empirically, and little is known about what kind of people are likely to be compelled by these different motives. This study had three goals. First, we aimed to use construct validation to test whether develop health, environmental, and animal rights motives for a vegetarian diet could be distinguished. Second, we evaluated whether these motivations were associated with different demographic, behavioral, and personality profiles in three diverse samples. Third, we examined whether peoples' motivations were related to responses to vegetarian advocacy materials. We created the Vegetarian Eating Motives Inventory, a 15-item measure whose structure was invariant across three samples (N = 1006, 1004, 5478) and two languages (English and Dutch). Using this measure, we found that health was the most common motive for non-vegetarians to consider vegetarian diets and it had the broadest array of correlates, which primarily involved communal and agentic values. Correlates of environmental and animal rights motives were limited, but these motives were strong and specific predictors of advocacy materials in a fourth sample (N = 739). These results provide researchers with a useful tool for identifying vegetarian motives among both vegetarian and non-vegetarian respondents, offer useful insights into the nomological net of vegetarian motivations, and provide advocates with guidance about how to best target campaigns promoting a vegetarian diet.
健康、环境和动物权利是西方社会人们选择素食的三个主要原因。然而,这些动机是否可以在经验上区分开来,以及什么样的人可能受到这些不同动机的影响,目前还不清楚。本研究有三个目标。首先,我们旨在使用结构验证来检验是否可以区分健康、环境和动物权利的素食动机。其次,我们评估了这些动机是否与三个不同样本中的不同人口统计学、行为和人格特征相关。第三,我们研究了人们的动机是否与对素食宣传材料的反应有关。我们创建了素食饮食动机量表(VEI),这是一个 15 项的测量工具,其结构在三个样本(N=1006、1004、5478)和两种语言(英语和荷兰语)中是不变的。使用这个量表,我们发现健康是最常见的非素食者考虑素食的原因,它与最多的共通和能动性价值观相关。环境和动物权利动机的相关性有限,但这些动机是强烈而具体的素食倡导材料的预测因素,在第四个样本(N=739)中得到了验证。这些结果为研究人员提供了一种有用的工具,可以在素食者和非素食者受访者中识别素食动机,为素食动机的规范网络提供了有用的见解,并为倡导者提供了有关如何最好地针对推广素食饮食的运动的指导。