Olthof Allard W, van Ooijen Peter M A, Rezazade Mehrizi Mohammad H
Department of Radiology, Treant Health Care Group, Dr. G.H. Amshoffweg 1, Hoogeveen, The Netherlands.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, Hanzeplein 1, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Neuroradiology. 2020 Oct;62(10):1265-1278. doi: 10.1007/s00234-020-02424-w. Epub 2020 Apr 22.
To conduct a systematic review of the possibilities of artificial intelligence (AI) in neuroradiology by performing an objective, systematic assessment of available applications. To analyse the potential impacts of AI applications on the work of neuroradiologists.
We identified AI applications offered on the market during the period 2017-2019. We systematically collected and structured information in a relational database and coded for the characteristics of the applications, their functionalities for the radiology workflow and their potential impacts in terms of 'supporting', 'extending' and 'replacing' radiology tasks.
We identified 37 AI applications in the domain of neuroradiology from 27 vendors, together offering 111 functionalities. The majority of functionalities 'support' radiologists, especially for the detection and interpretation of image findings. The second-largest group of functionalities 'extends' the possibilities of radiologists by providing quantitative information about pathological findings. A small but noticeable portion of functionalities seek to 'replace' certain radiology tasks.
Artificial intelligence in neuroradiology is not only in the stage of development and testing but also available for clinical practice. The majority of functionalities support radiologists or extend their tasks. None of the applications can replace the entire radiology profession, but a few applications can do so for a limited set of tasks. Scientific validation of the AI products is more limited than the regulatory approval.
通过对现有应用进行客观、系统的评估,对人工智能(AI)在神经放射学中的应用可能性进行系统评价。分析AI应用对神经放射科医生工作的潜在影响。
我们确定了2017 - 2019年期间市场上提供的AI应用。我们在一个关系数据库中系统地收集和整理信息,并对应用的特征、其在放射学工作流程中的功能以及在“支持”“扩展”和“替代”放射学任务方面的潜在影响进行编码。
我们从27家供应商中确定了神经放射学领域的37种AI应用,这些应用共提供了111种功能。大多数功能“支持”放射科医生,特别是在图像发现的检测和解读方面。第二大功能组通过提供有关病理发现的定量信息“扩展”了放射科医生的能力。一小部分但值得注意的功能试图“替代”某些放射学任务。
神经放射学中的人工智能不仅处于开发和测试阶段,也可用于临床实践。大多数功能支持放射科医生或扩展其任务。没有任何应用能够完全取代放射科专业,但有一些应用可以在有限的一组任务中做到这一点。AI产品的科学验证比监管批准更为有限。