Nassar Ayman, Torres-Rua Alfonso, Kustas William, Nieto Hector, McKee Mac, Hipps Lawrence, Stevens David, Alfieri Joseph, Prueger John, Alsina Maria Mar, McKee Lynn, Coopmans Calvin, Sanchez Luis, Dokoozlian Nick
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322, USA.
U. S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Hydrology and Remote Sensing Laboratory, Beltsville, MD 20705, USA.
Remote Sens (Basel). 2020;12(3):342. doi: 10.3390/rs12030342.
Evapotranspiration () is a key variable for hydrology and irrigation water management, with significant importance in drought-stricken regions of the western US. This is particularly true for California, which grows much of the high-value perennial crops in the US. The advent of small Unmanned Aerial System () with sensor technology similar to satellite platforms allows for the estimation of high-resolution at plant spacing scale for individual fields. However, while multiple efforts have been made to estimate from products, the sensitivity of models to different model grid size/resolution in complex canopies, such as vineyards, is still unknown. The variability of row spacing, canopy structure, and distance between fields makes this information necessary because additional complexity processing individual fields. Therefore, processing the entire image at a fixed resolution that is potentially larger than the plant-row separation is more efficient. From a computational perspective, there would be an advantage to running models at much coarser resolutions than the very fine native pixel size from imagery for operational applications. In this study, the Two-Source Energy Balance with a dual temperature () model, which uses remotely sensed soil/substrate and canopy temperature from imagery, was used to estimate and identify the impact of spatial domain scale under different vine phenological conditions. The analysis relies upon high-resolution imagery collected during multiple years and times by the Utah State University program over a commercial vineyard located near Lodi, California. This project is part of the USDA-Agricultural Research Service Grape Remote Sensing Atmospheric Profile and Evapotranspiration eXperiment (). Original spectral and thermal imagery data from were at 10 cm and 60 cm per pixel, respectively, and multiple spatial domain scales (3.6, 7.2, 14.4, and 30 m) were evaluated and compared against eddy covariance () measurements. Results indicated that the model is only slightly affected in the estimation of the net radiation ( ) and the soil heat flux () at different spatial resolutions, while the sensible and latent heat fluxes ( and , respectively) are significantly affected by coarse grid sizes. The results indicated overestimation of and underestimation of values, particularly at Landsat scale (30 m). This refers to the non-linear relationship between the land surface temperature () and the normalized difference vegetation index () at coarse model resolution. Another predominant reason for reduction in was the decrease in the aerodynamic resistance ( ), which is a function of the friction velocity F) that varies with mean canopy height and roughness length. While a small increase in grid size can be implemented, this increase should be limited to less than twice the smallest row spacing present in the imagery. The results also indicated that the mean at field scale is reduced by 10% to 20% at coarser resolutions, while the with-in field variability in values decreased significantly at the larger grid sizes and ranged between approximately 15% and 45%. This implies that, while the field-scale values of are fairly reliable at larger grid sizes, the with-in field variability limits its use for precision agriculture applications.
蒸散量(ET)是水文和灌溉用水管理的关键变量,在美国西部干旱地区具有重要意义。加利福尼亚州尤其如此,该州种植了美国大部分高价值多年生作物。配备与卫星平台类似传感器技术的小型无人机系统(UAS)的出现,使得能够在单个田地的植株间距尺度上估算高分辨率的ET。然而,尽管已经做出多项努力从UAS产品估算ET,但在复杂冠层(如葡萄园)中,ET模型对不同模型网格大小/分辨率的敏感性仍然未知。行距、冠层结构和田间距离的变异性使得该信息变得必要,因为处理单个田地会增加复杂性。因此,以可能大于植株行间距的固定分辨率处理整个图像效率更高。从计算角度来看,在操作应用中以比UAS图像非常精细的原始像素尺寸粗得多的分辨率运行模型具有优势。在本研究中,使用了双源能量平衡双温度(TSEB)模型,该模型利用UAS图像中的遥感土壤/基质和冠层温度来估算ET,并识别不同葡萄物候条件下空间域尺度的影响。分析依赖于犹他州立大学UAS项目在加利福尼亚州洛迪附近的一个商业葡萄园在多年和多个时间收集的高分辨率图像。该项目是美国农业部农业研究服务局葡萄遥感大气剖面和蒸散实验(GRAPEX)的一部分。来自UAS的原始光谱和热图像数据分别为每像素10厘米和60厘米,并评估了多个空间域尺度(3.6、7.2、14.4和30米),并与涡度协方差(EC)测量值进行了比较。结果表明,TSEB模型在不同空间分辨率下对净辐射(Rn)和土壤热通量(G)的估算仅受到轻微影响,而感热通量和潜热通量(分别为H和LE)则受到粗网格大小的显著影响。结果表明,ET值存在高估和低估,特别是在陆地卫星尺度(30米)。这是指在粗模型分辨率下陆地表面温度(LST)与归一化植被指数(NDVI)之间的非线性关系。ET降低的另一个主要原因是空气动力学阻力(ra)的降低,它是摩擦速度(u*)的函数,随平均冠层高度和粗糙度长度而变化。虽然可以实现网格大小的小幅增加,但这种增加应限制在UAS图像中最小行距的两倍以内。结果还表明,在较粗分辨率下,田间尺度的平均ET降低了10%至20%,而在较大网格大小下,ET值的田间变异性显著降低,范围约为15%至45%。这意味着,虽然在较大网格大小下田间尺度的ET值相当可靠,但田间变异性限制了其在精准农业应用中的使用。