Oral Pathology Department, School of Dentistry, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.
TelessaudeRS-UFRGS, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2020 Jun 5;15(6):e0233572. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0233572. eCollection 2020.
EstomatoNet was created in the south of Brazil to provides specialist support over a web-based platform to primary care dentists for diagnosis of oral lesions. To evaluate the usability of EstomatoNet and to identify user perceptions regarding their expectations and difficulties with the system; and to compare the perceptions of regular users of the service to those of first-time users. Sixteen dentists were selected for the study: 8 were frequent users of EstomatoNet and 8 were residents who had never used the Platform. To assess usability, participants were required to request telediagnosis support for a fictional case provided by the research team. During the process of uploading the information and sending the request, users were asked to "think out loud," expressing their perceptions. The session was observed by an examiner with remote access to the user's screen (via Skype). After the simulation, users completed the System Usability Scale (SyUS), a validated tool with scores ranging from 0 to 100. The mean SyUS score assigned by frequent users was 84.7±6.6, vs. 82.2±9.3 for residents (satisfactory usability: score above 68). The difference between the groups was not statistically significant (Student t test, P = .55). The residents group took longer (347.1±101.1s) to complete the task than frequent users (252.8±80.3s); however, the difference between the groups was not statistically significant (Student t test, P = .06). In their subjective evaluation, users suggested the inclusion of a field to add further information on outcomes and resolution of the case and changes in the position of the "Send" button to improve workflow. The present results indicate satisfactory usability of EstomatoNet. The Platform seems to meet the needs of users regardless of how experienced they are; nevertheless, a few minor changes in some steps would improve the tool.
EstomatoNet 是在巴西南部创建的,旨在通过基于网络的平台为初级保健牙医提供专家支持,以诊断口腔病变。评估 EstomatoNet 的可用性,并确定用户对系统的期望和困难的看法;并比较该服务的常规用户和首次用户的看法。选择了 16 名牙医进行研究:8 名是 EstomatoNet 的频繁用户,8 名是从未使用过该平台的居民。为了评估可用性,要求参与者请求研究团队提供的虚构案例的远程诊断支持。在上传信息和发送请求的过程中,用户被要求“大声思考”,表达他们的看法。会话由一位具有远程访问用户屏幕权限的考官(通过 Skype)进行观察。模拟结束后,用户完成了经过验证的系统可用性量表(SyUS),该量表的分数范围为 0 到 100。频繁用户的平均 SyUS 得分为 84.7±6.6,而居民为 82.2±9.3(可接受的可用性:得分高于 68)。两组之间的差异没有统计学意义(学生 t 检验,P =.55)。居民组完成任务的时间(347.1±101.1s)比频繁用户(252.8±80.3s)长;然而,两组之间的差异没有统计学意义(学生 t 检验,P =.06)。在他们的主观评价中,用户建议在字段中添加有关病例结果和解决情况以及“发送”按钮位置更改的进一步信息,以改善工作流程。目前的结果表明 EstomatoNet 的可用性令人满意。该平台似乎满足了用户的需求,无论他们的经验如何;然而,在一些步骤中进行一些小的更改将可以改进该工具。