Fallon Naomi, Dillon Stephanie A
School of Sport and Health Sciences, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, England.
Front Nutr. 2020 May 20;7:72. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2020.00072. eCollection 2020.
Vegan and vegetarian diets are becoming increasingly popular in the UK. Due to the avoidance of animal products there can be significant differences in nutrient intakes between meat-eaters and vegetarians, and especially vegans. Importantly, research has identified that both vegans and vegetarians may be vulnerable to low intakes of some micronutrients. The aim of this study was to investigate micronutrient intake in omnivorous, vegetarian and vegan women. In total, 62 women (26 omnivores, 16 vegetarians, 20 vegans, mean age 31.6 ± 12.4 y, mean BMI 24.1 ± 1.6 kg/m ) completed 4-day diet diaries. Diet intake data was analyzed using Nutritics and nutrient intake levels were compared with national dietary recommendations (RNIs). Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS, with differences between the groups identified using ANOVA with Bonferroni correction. All groups recorded intakes of vitamin D, iron, iodine and selenium below RNI. The vegan group had significantly lower intakes of vitamin D, vitamin B12, calcium, selenium and iodine than vegetarians and omnivores ( < 0.05), with particularly low intakes of selenium (24.7 ± 11.9 μg) and iodine (24.4 ± 12.7 μg). These results suggest that adult women in the UK are at risk of low intakes of several vitamins and minerals, with the exclusion of animal products conferring an additional vulnerability, particularly with respect to selenium and iodine, both of which play important roles in thyroid hormone production. This study highlights iodine and selenium intakes to be a concern amongst women who follow vegan diets, and the necessity of further research to identify if low intake translates to biochemical markers and functional status.
纯素饮食和素食饮食在英国越来越受欢迎。由于避免食用动物产品,肉食者和素食者(尤其是纯素食者)的营养摄入量可能存在显著差异。重要的是,研究发现纯素食者和素食者都可能容易出现某些微量营养素摄入不足的情况。本研究的目的是调查杂食、素食和纯素食女性的微量营养素摄入量。共有62名女性(26名杂食者、16名素食者、20名纯素食者,平均年龄31.6±12.4岁,平均BMI 24.1±1.6kg/m²)完成了为期4天的饮食日记。使用Nutritics分析饮食摄入数据,并将营养素摄入水平与国家饮食建议(RNIs)进行比较。使用SPSS进行统计分析,通过方差分析和Bonferroni校正确定组间差异。所有组记录的维生素D、铁、碘和硒摄入量均低于RNIs。纯素食组的维生素D、维生素B12、钙、硒和碘摄入量显著低于素食者和杂食者(P<0.05),其中硒(24.7±11.9μg)和碘(24.4±12.7μg)的摄入量尤其低。这些结果表明,英国成年女性有几种维生素和矿物质摄入不足的风险,排除动物产品会带来额外的易感性,特别是在硒和碘方面,这两种元素在甲状腺激素产生中都起着重要作用。本研究强调碘和硒的摄入量是遵循纯素饮食的女性需要关注的问题,并且有必要进一步研究以确定低摄入量是否转化为生化指标和功能状态。