Schrenk Dieter, Bodin Laurent, Chipman James Kevin, Del Mazo Jesús, Grasl-Kraupp Bettina, Hogstrand Christer, Hoogenboom Laurentius Ron, Leblanc Jean-Charles, Nebbia Carlo Stefano, Nielsen Elsa, Ntzani Evangelia, Petersen Annette, Sand Salomon, Schwerdtle Tanja, Vleminckx Christiane, Wallace Heather, Alexander Jan, Cottrill Bruce, Dusemund Birgit, Mulder Patrick, Arcella Davide, Baert Katleen, Cascio Claudia, Steinkellner Hans, Bignami Margherita
EFSA J. 2019 Nov 5;17(11):e05860. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2019.5860. eCollection 2019 Nov.
The European Commission asked EFSA for a scientific opinion on the risks for animal and human health related to the presence of quinolizidine alkaloids (QAs) in feed and food. This risk assessment is limited to QAs occurring in s species/varieties relevant for animal and human consumption in Europe (i.e. L., L., L. and Sweet). Information on the toxicity of QAs in animals and humans is limited. Following acute exposure to sparteine (reference compound), anticholinergic effects and changes in cardiac electric conductivity are considered to be critical for human hazard characterisation. The CONTAM Panel used a margin of exposure (MOE) approach identifying a lowest single oral effective dose of 0.16 mg sparteine/kg body weight as reference point to characterise the risk following acute exposure. No reference point could be identified to characterise the risk of chronic exposure. Because of similar modes of action for QAs, the CONTAM Panel used a group approach assuming dose additivity. For food, the highest mean concentration of Total QAs (TotQAs) (i.e. the 6 most abundant QAs) was found in lupin seed samples classified as 'Lupins (dry) and similar-'. Due to the limited data on occurrence and consumption, dietary exposure was calculated for some specific scenarios and no full human health risk characterisation was possible. The calculated margin of exposures (MOEs) may indicate a risk for some consumers. For example, when lupin seeds are consumed without a debittering step, or as debittered lupin seeds high in QA content and when 'lupin-based meat imitates' are consumed. For horses, companion and farm animals, other than salmonids, the available database on adverse effects was too limited to identify no-observed-adverse-effect levels and/or lowest-observed-adverse-effect levels and no risk characterisation was possible. For salmonids, the CONTAM Panel considers the risk for adverse effects to be low.
欧盟委员会要求欧洲食品安全局就饲料和食品中喹诺里西啶生物碱(QAs)对动物和人类健康的风险提供科学意见。该风险评估仅限于欧洲与动物和人类消费相关的物种/品种(即羽扇豆属的某些物种)中出现的QAs。关于QAs对动物和人类毒性的信息有限。急性接触金雀花碱(参考化合物)后,抗胆碱能作用和心脏电导率变化被认为是人类危害特征描述的关键。CONTAM专家组采用了暴露边际(MOE)方法,确定最低单次口服有效剂量为0.16毫克金雀花碱/千克体重作为参考点,以描述急性接触后的风险。无法确定用于描述慢性接触风险的参考点。由于QAs的作用方式相似,CONTAM专家组采用了分组方法,假设剂量相加。对于食品,在归类为“羽扇豆(干)及类似物”的羽扇豆种子样本中发现总QAs(TotQAs,即6种最丰富的QAs)的最高平均浓度。由于关于含量和消费量的数据有限,针对一些特定情况计算了膳食暴露量,无法进行全面的人类健康风险特征描述。计算出的暴露边际(MOEs)可能表明对某些消费者存在风险。例如,当食用未经去苦步骤的羽扇豆种子时,或食用QA含量高的去苦羽扇豆种子时,以及食用“羽扇豆基肉类仿制品”时。对于马、伴侣动物和农场动物(鲑鱼除外),关于不良反应的现有数据库过于有限,无法确定无观察到不良反应水平和/或最低观察到不良反应水平,因此无法进行风险特征描述。对于鲑鱼,CONTAM专家组认为不良反应风险较低。