Centre for Mathematical Modelling of Infectious Disease and Department of Global Health and Development, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
CARE India, Patna, Bihar, India.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2020 Jul 9;14(7):e0008422. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0008422. eCollection 2020 Jul.
The elimination programme for visceral leishmaniasis (VL) in India has seen great progress, with total cases decreasing by over 80% since 2010 and many blocks now reporting zero cases from year to year. Prompt diagnosis and treatment is critical to continue progress and avoid epidemics in the increasingly susceptible population. Short-term forecasts could be used to highlight anomalies in incidence and support health service logistics. The model which best fits the data is not necessarily most useful for prediction, yet little empirical work has been done to investigate the balance between fit and predictive performance.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We developed statistical models of monthly VL case counts at block level. By evaluating a set of randomly-generated models, we found that fit and one-month-ahead prediction were strongly correlated and that rolling updates to model parameters as data accrued were not crucial for accurate prediction. The final model incorporated auto-regression over four months, spatial correlation between neighbouring blocks, and seasonality. Ninety-four percent of 10-90% prediction intervals from this model captured the observed count during a 24-month test period. Comparison of one-, three- and four-month-ahead predictions from the final model fit demonstrated that a longer time horizon yielded only a small sacrifice in predictive power for the vast majority of blocks.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: The model developed is informed by routinely-collected surveillance data as it accumulates, and predictions are sufficiently accurate and precise to be useful. Such forecasts could, for example, be used to guide stock requirements for rapid diagnostic tests and drugs. More comprehensive data on factors thought to influence geographic variation in VL burden could be incorporated, and might better explain the heterogeneity between blocks and improve uniformity of predictive performance. Integration of the approach in the management of the VL programme would be an important step to ensuring continued successful control.
印度的内脏利什曼病(VL)消除规划取得了重大进展,自 2010 年以来,总病例数减少了 80%以上,许多地区现在每年报告的病例数为零。及时诊断和治疗对于继续取得进展和避免易感人群中出现疫情至关重要。短期预测可用于突出发病率中的异常情况,并支持卫生服务后勤工作。最适合数据的模型不一定对预测最有用,但很少有实证工作来研究拟合度和预测性能之间的平衡。
方法/主要发现:我们在区块层面上开发了月度 VL 病例数的统计模型。通过评估一组随机生成的模型,我们发现拟合度和一个月的预测高度相关,并且随着数据的积累,对模型参数进行滚动更新对于准确预测并不是至关重要的。最终模型纳入了四个月的自回归、相邻区块之间的空间相关性和季节性。该模型的 10-90%预测区间中有 94%在 24 个月的测试期内捕捉到了观察到的计数。最终模型的一个月、三个月和四个月的预测结果的比较表明,对于绝大多数区块,更长的时间范围仅会导致预测能力略有下降。
结论/意义:该模型是根据常规收集的监测数据随着时间的推移而制定的,预测结果足够准确和精确,具有实用性。例如,此类预测可用于指导快速诊断测试和药物的库存需求。可以纳入更多关于被认为影响 VL 负担地理变异的因素的综合数据,这可能会更好地解释区块之间的异质性并提高预测性能的一致性。将该方法纳入 VL 规划的管理中是确保持续成功控制的重要步骤。