Tagbor Harry, Antwi Gifty, Dogbe Joslin
Department of Community Health.
Department of Child Health, School of Medical Sciences, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana.
Res Rep Trop Med. 2014 Jun 19;5:23-33. doi: 10.2147/RRTM.S34683. eCollection 2014.
Inadequately controlled malaria infection in pregnancy is associated with poor maternal and fetal outcomes. However, there are important questions about drug safety for mothers with malaria and their fetuses as, currently, there is limited safety data on many of the medications used. The objective of this review is to determine from published evidence the safety of antimalarial drugs exposure during early pregnancy, focusing on abortions, stillbirths, and congenital abnormalities.
We searched PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Malaria in Pregnancy databases from their inception to June 2013, inclusive, for reports published in English only. Data were extracted on exposure to antimalarial drugs during early pregnancy and adverse pregnancy outcomes including congenital abnormalities, stillbirth, and miscarriage.
Twenty-two publications including one abstract with a total of 6,333 early pregnancy exposures to antimalarial agents used for treatment and/or prevention of malaria in pregnancy met the inclusion criteria. More than 40% of the pregnancies were exposed to mefloquine, about 10% to artemisinin based regimens and, 15.2% and 14.7% were exposed to chloroquine and quinine, respectively. A total of 1,199 adverse outcomes including abortions, stillbirths, and congenital abnormalities were reported. The reported absolute risks of adverse outcomes were similar for all the antimalarial exposures, but, in two publications, increased risk of stillbirths was linked to mefloquine exposure. Extensive heterogeneity and variability in the way in which authors assessed, recorded, and reported safety data precluded formal meta-analysis.
The absolute estimates of risks obtained in the included studies are difficult to interpret and the clinical significance of any association of adverse outcomes reported with antimalarial exposure in early pregnancy is uncertain. Well planned, executed, and analyzed studies are needed to confirm whether there is increased risk for adverse fetal outcomes attributable to exposure of first trimester pregnancies to antimalarials compared to relevant controls.
孕期疟疾感染控制不佳与母婴不良结局相关。然而,对于患疟疾的母亲及其胎儿而言,药物安全性存在重要问题,因为目前许多所用药物的安全性数据有限。本综述的目的是根据已发表的证据确定孕早期接触抗疟药物的安全性,重点关注流产、死产和先天性异常。
我们检索了PubMed、Embase、Cochrane图书馆和《孕期疟疾》数据库,从其创建至2013年6月(含),仅检索英文发表的报告。提取了孕早期接触抗疟药物以及不良妊娠结局(包括先天性异常、死产和流产)的数据。
22篇出版物(包括1篇摘要),共计6333例孕早期接触用于治疗和/或预防孕期疟疾的抗疟药物的病例符合纳入标准。超过40%的妊娠接触了甲氟喹,约10%接触了青蒿素类方案,15.2%和14.7%的妊娠分别接触了氯喹和奎宁。共报告了1199例不良结局,包括流产、死产和先天性异常。所有抗疟药物接触的不良结局报告的绝对风险相似,但在两篇出版物中,死产风险增加与甲氟喹接触有关。作者评估、记录和报告安全性数据的方式存在广泛的异质性和变异性,因此无法进行正式的荟萃分析。
纳入研究中获得的风险绝对估计值难以解释,且孕早期接触抗疟药物所报告的任何不良结局关联的临床意义尚不确定。需要精心规划、实施和分析的研究来确认与相关对照组相比,孕早期妊娠接触抗疟药物是否会增加不良胎儿结局的风险。