Salman Muhammad, Mustafa Zia Ul, Rao Alina Zeeshan, Khan Qurat-Ul-Ain, Asif Noman, Hussain Khalid, Shehzadi Naureen, Khan Muhammad Farhan Ali, Rashid Amir
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, The University of Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan.
Department of Pharmacy, District Headquarter Hospital, Pakpattan, Pakistan.
Front Pharmacol. 2020 Jul 14;11:1026. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.01026. eCollection 2020.
Deaths-related to medications errors are common in Pakistan but these are not accurately reported. Recently, the death of a 9 months old baby due to abrupt administration of 15% potassium chloride injection sparked the issue of high alert medications (HAMs) related errors in the country. Since drug administration is the prime responsibility of the nurses, it is pivotal that they possess good knowledge of HAMs. Since there is no published data regarding the knowledge of HAMs among Pakistani nurses, we aimed to assess knowledge of HAMs among registered nurses of Pakistan.
A cross-sectional study was conducted among registered nurses, recruited using a convenient sampling technique, from 29 hospitals all over the Punjab Province. Data were collected using a validated self-administered instrument. All data were entered and analyzed using SPSS version 22.
The study sample was comprised of 2,363 registered nurses (staff nurses = 94.8%, head nurses = 5.2%). Around 63% were working in tertiary hospitals whereas almost 25 and 12% were from district headquarter hospitals and tehsil headquarter hospitals, respectively. Around 84% of the study participants achieved scores <70%, indicating majority of Pakistani nurses having poor knowledge of HAMs administration as well as regulation. There was no significant difference of overall knowledge among age, hospitals, departments, training, designations, qualification, and experience categories. Major obstacles encountered during HAMs administration were "getting uncertain answers from colleagues" (72.9%), "unavailability of suitable person to consult" (61.1%) and "receiving verbal orders" (55.6%).
Our study revealed the serious inadequacies in HAMs knowledge among Pakistani nurses which may lead to adverse patient outcomes. Nurses should receive comprehensive pharmacology knowledge not only during in-school nursing education but also as hospital-based continuing education. Moreover, it is of immense importance to bridge the gaps between physicians, clinical pharmacists, and nurses through effective communication as this will help reduce medication errors and improve patient care.
在巴基斯坦,与用药错误相关的死亡很常见,但这些并未得到准确报告。最近,一名9个月大的婴儿因突然注射15%氯化钾注射液而死亡,这引发了该国与高警示药物(HAMs)相关错误的问题。由于给药是护士的主要职责,因此他们掌握HAMs的良好知识至关重要。由于没有关于巴基斯坦护士对HAMs知识的已发表数据,我们旨在评估巴基斯坦注册护士对HAMs的知识。
采用方便抽样技术,从旁遮普省各地的29家医院招募注册护士,进行横断面研究。使用经过验证的自填式工具收集数据。所有数据均使用SPSS 22版录入和分析。
研究样本包括2363名注册护士(普通护士=94.8%,护士长=5.2%)。约63%的护士在三级医院工作,而分别约25%和12%的护士来自地区总部医院和乡镇总部医院。约84%的研究参与者得分<70%,这表明大多数巴基斯坦护士对HAMs的给药及管理知识掌握较差。在年龄、医院、科室、培训、职称、学历和工作经验类别之间,总体知识水平没有显著差异。在HAMs给药过程中遇到的主要障碍是“从同事那里得到不确定的答案”(72.9%)、“没有合适的人可供咨询”(61.1%)和“接收口头医嘱”(55.6%)。
我们的研究揭示了巴基斯坦护士在HAMs知识方面存在严重不足,这可能导致患者出现不良后果。护士不仅应在学校护理教育期间,还应作为医院继续教育接受全面的药理学知识。此外,通过有效的沟通弥合医生、临床药剂师和护士之间的差距非常重要,因为这将有助于减少用药错误并改善患者护理。