University of Groningen, Netherlands.
Macquarie University.
Lang Speech. 2021 Sep;64(3):681-692. doi: 10.1177/0023830920953169. Epub 2020 Aug 28.
Alcohol intoxication is known to affect many aspects of human behavior and cognition; one of such affected systems is articulation during speech production. Although much research has revealed that alcohol negatively impacts pronunciation in a first language (L1), there is only initial evidence suggesting a potential beneficial effect of inebriation on articulation in a non-native language (L2). The aim of this study was thus to compare the effect of alcohol consumption on pronunciation in an L1 and an L2. Participants who had ingested different amounts of alcohol provided speech samples in their L1 (Dutch) and L2 (English), and native speakers of each language subsequently rated the pronunciation of these samples on their intelligibility (for the L1) and accent nativelikeness (for the L2). These data were analyzed with generalized additive mixed modeling. Participants' blood alcohol concentration indeed negatively affected pronunciation in L1, but it produced no significant effect on the L2 accent ratings. The expected negative impact of alcohol on L1 articulation can be explained by reduction in fine motor control. We present two hypotheses to account for the absence of any effects of intoxication on L2 pronunciation: (1) there may be a reduction in L1 interference on L2 speech due to decreased motor control or (2) alcohol may produce a differential effect on each of the two linguistic subsystems.
酒精中毒已知会影响人类行为和认知的许多方面;其中一个受影响的系统是言语产生过程中的发音。尽管大量研究表明酒精会对母语(L1)的发音产生负面影响,但仅有初步证据表明醉酒对非母语(L2)的发音可能有有益的影响。因此,本研究旨在比较酒精摄入对 L1 和 L2 发音的影响。摄入不同量酒精的参与者用他们的 L1(荷兰语)和 L2(英语)提供了语音样本,随后母语为这两种语言的人对这些样本的发音清晰度(对于 L1)和口音母语相似度(对于 L2)进行了评分。使用广义加性混合模型对这些数据进行了分析。参与者的血液酒精浓度确实会对 L1 的发音产生负面影响,但对 L2 的口音评分没有产生显著影响。酒精对 L1 发音的预期负面影响可以用精细运动控制的减少来解释。我们提出了两个假设来解释醉酒对 L2 发音没有任何影响的原因:(1)由于运动控制的降低,L1 干扰对 L2 言语的影响可能会减少;(2)酒精可能对两个语言子系统中的每一个产生不同的影响。