Department of Computer Science and Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA.
Department of Bioengineering, Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA.
Tissue Eng Part A. 2020 Dec;26(23-24):1359-1368. doi: 10.1089/ten.TEA.2020.0191. Epub 2020 Oct 15.
Various material compositions have been successfully used in 3D printing with promising applications as scaffolds in tissue engineering. However, identifying suitable printing conditions for new materials requires extensive experimentation in a time and resource-demanding process. This study investigates the use of Machine Learning (ML) for distinguishing between printing configurations that are likely to result in low-quality prints and printing configurations that are more promising as a first step toward the development of a recommendation system for identifying suitable printing conditions. The ML-based framework takes as input the printing conditions regarding the material composition and the printing parameters and predicts the quality of the resulting print as either "low" or "high." We investigate two ML-based approaches: a direct classification-based approach that trains a classifier to distinguish between low- and high-quality prints and an indirect approach that uses a regression ML model that approximates the values of a printing quality metric. Both modes are built upon Random Forests. We trained and evaluated the models on a dataset that was generated in a previous study, which investigated fabrication of porous polymer scaffolds by means of extrusion-based 3D printing with a full-factorial design. Our results show that both models were able to correctly label the majority of the tested configurations while a simpler linear ML model was not effective. Additionally, our analysis showed that a full factorial design for data collection can lead to redundancies in the data, in the context of ML, and we propose a more efficient data collection strategy.
各种材料成分已经成功地用于 3D 打印,作为组织工程中的支架具有广阔的应用前景。然而,确定新材料的合适打印条件需要在时间和资源密集型过程中进行广泛的实验。本研究探讨了机器学习(ML)在区分可能导致低质量打印的打印配置和更有前途的打印配置方面的应用,作为开发识别合适打印条件的推荐系统的第一步。基于 ML 的框架将材料成分和打印参数的打印条件作为输入,并预测所得打印品的质量是“低”还是“高”。我们研究了两种基于 ML 的方法:一种是直接基于分类的方法,该方法训练分类器来区分低质量和高质量的打印品;另一种是间接方法,使用回归 ML 模型来近似打印质量指标的值。这两种模式都是基于随机森林构建的。我们在之前研究中生成的数据集上对模型进行了训练和评估,该研究通过基于挤出的 3D 打印方法来制造多孔聚合物支架,采用全因子设计。我们的结果表明,这两种模型都能够正确标记大多数测试配置,而更简单的线性 ML 模型则无效。此外,我们的分析表明,在 ML 中,全因子设计的数据收集可能会导致数据冗余,我们提出了一种更有效的数据收集策略。