Coleman Cliff, Peterson-Perry Sylvia, Sachdeva Bhavaya, Kobus Amy, Garvin Roger
Oregon Health & Science University, Department of Family Medicine.
Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR.
PRiMER. 2017 Dec 6;1:22. doi: 10.22454/PRiMER.2017.703541. eCollection 2017 Sep.
Improving education about health literacy for health care professionals has been recommended, and many US family medicine residency programs have developed such curricula. Few studies have evaluated the effectiveness of health literacy curricula for health care professionals. This pilot study aimed to determine whether a longitudinal health literacy curriculum for family medicine residents could achieve long-term sustained improvements in health literacy knowledge and clear communication practices.
Self-reported pre- and postassessments were conducted for a series of four health literacy didactic and experiential trainings over 11 months with a cohort of 12 first-year family medicine residents (study adequately powered for cohort of 10 or more).
Five out of five health literacy knowledge items showed sustained significant improvement immediately after the initial didactic training. Two out of eight clear communication behaviors (eliciting patients' questions through an open-ended approach, and using a teach-back method to check for patients' understanding) showed sustained significant improvements in the 11-month follow-up period. The remaining six behaviors demonstrated a saw-tooth pattern, wherein each training session produced improvements in planned behaviors, which were, however, not maintained at subsequent follow-up assessments.
These data suggest that residents learned the cognitive material related to health literacy and clear communication easily, but had difficulty integrating many trained skills into clinical practice, despite the use of experiential learning techniques. Future studies should use an observational design to assess clear communication behaviors, and should include assessment of potential barriers to implementing clear communication skills in clinical practice.
有人建议提高医护人员的健康素养教育水平,许多美国家庭医学住院医师培训项目也已制定了相关课程。很少有研究评估医护人员健康素养课程的效果。这项试点研究旨在确定针对家庭医学住院医师的纵向健康素养课程是否能在健康素养知识和清晰沟通实践方面实现长期持续的改善。
对一组12名一年级家庭医学住院医师在11个月内进行了一系列四次健康素养理论与实践培训,并进行了自我报告的课前和课后评估(该研究对10名或更多的队列有足够的统计学效力)。
五项健康素养知识项目中有五项在初始理论培训后立即显示出持续的显著改善。八项清晰沟通行为中有两项(通过开放式方法引出患者问题,以及使用反馈法检查患者理解情况)在11个月的随访期内显示出持续的显著改善。其余六项行为呈现出锯齿状模式,即每次培训课程都能使计划行为有所改善,但在随后的随访评估中并未维持。
这些数据表明,住院医师很容易学习到与健康素养和清晰沟通相关的认知材料,但尽管使用了体验式学习技术,他们在将许多所学技能融入临床实践方面仍存在困难。未来的研究应采用观察性设计来评估清晰沟通行为,并应包括对临床实践中实施清晰沟通技能的潜在障碍的评估。