Zhou Jiena, Shi Zhihao, Zhou Lifang, Hu Yong, Zhang Meibian
Occupational Health and Radiation Protection Department, Zhejiang Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Hangzhou, China.
School of medicine, Ningbo University, Ningbo, China.
BMJ Open. 2020 Sep 28;10(9):e039576. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-039576.
Most of the Chinese occupational population are becoming at risk of noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL). However, there is a limited number of literature reviews on occupational NIHL in China. This study aimed to analyse the prevalence and characteristics of occupational NIHL in the Chinese population using data from relevant studies.
Systematic review and meta-analysis.
From December 2019 to February 2020, we searched the literature through databases, including Web of Science, PubMed, MEDLINE, Scopus, the China National Knowledge Internet, Chinese Sci-Tech Journal Database (weip.com), WanFang Database and China United Library Database, for studies on NIHL in China published in 1993-2019 and analysed the correlation between NIHL and occupational exposure to noise, including exposure to complex noise and coexposure to noise and chemicals.
A total of 71 865 workers aged 33.5±8.7 years were occupationally exposed to 98.6±7.2 dB(A) (A-weighted decibels) noise for a duration of 9.9±8.4 years in the transportation, mining and typical manufacturing industries. The prevalence of occupational NIHL in China was 21.3%, of which 30.2% was related to high-frequency NIHL (HFNIHL), 9.0% to speech-frequency NIHL and 5.8% to noise-induced deafness. Among manufacturing workers, complex noise contributed to greater HFNIHL than Gaussian noise (overall weighted OR (OR)=1.95). Coexposure to noise and chemicals such as organic solvents, welding fumes, carbon monoxide and hydrogen sulfide led to greater HFNIHL than noise exposure alone (overall weighted OR=2.36). Male workers were more likely to experience HFNIHL than female workers (overall weighted OR=2.26). Age, noise level and exposure duration were also risk factors for HFNIHL (overall weighted OR=1.35, 5.63 and 1.75, respectively).
The high prevalence of occupational NIHL in China was related to the wide distribution of noise in different industries as well as high-level and long-term noise exposure. The prevalence was further aggravated by exposure to complex noise or coexposure to noise and specific chemicals. Additional efforts are needed to reduce occupational noise exposure in China.
中国大多数职业人群正面临噪声性听力损失(NIHL)的风险。然而,关于中国职业性NIHL的文献综述数量有限。本研究旨在利用相关研究数据分析中国人群职业性NIHL的患病率及特征。
系统评价和荟萃分析。
2019年12月至2020年2月,我们通过数据库检索文献,包括Web of Science、PubMed、MEDLINE、Scopus、中国知网、维普资讯网、万方数据库和全国图书馆参考咨询联盟,查找1993 - 2019年发表的关于中国NIHL的研究,并分析NIHL与职业噪声暴露之间的相关性,包括复杂噪声暴露以及噪声与化学物质的共同暴露。
在交通运输、采矿和典型制造业中,共有71865名年龄为33.5±8.7岁的工人职业性暴露于98.6±7.2 dB(A)(A声级)的噪声中,暴露时长为9.9±8.4年。中国职业性NIHL的患病率为21.3%,其中30.2%与高频NIHL(HFNIHL)有关,9.0%与言语频率NIHL有关,5.8%与噪声性耳聋有关。在制造业工人中,复杂噪声导致的HFNIHL高于高斯噪声(总体加权OR(比值比)=1.95)。噪声与有机溶剂、焊接烟尘、一氧化碳和硫化氢等化学物质共同暴露导致的HFNIHL高于单纯噪声暴露(总体加权OR = 2.36)。男性工人比女性工人更易发生HFNIHL(总体加权OR = 2.26)。年龄、噪声水平和暴露时长也是HFNIHL的危险因素(总体加权OR分别为1.35、5.63和1.75)。
中国职业性NIHL的高患病率与不同行业噪声的广泛分布以及高水平、长期的噪声暴露有关。暴露于复杂噪声或噪声与特定化学物质的共同暴露会使患病率进一步加重。中国需要做出更多努力来减少职业噪声暴露。