Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Mahidol University, Nakhon Pathom, Thailand.
International Health Policy Program, Ministry of Public Health, Nonthaburi, Thailand.
Health Expect. 2020 Dec;23(6):1594-1602. doi: 10.1111/hex.13142. Epub 2020 Oct 9.
Legislative provisions in Thailand's National Health Security Act 2002 mandate annual public hearings for providers, beneficiaries and other stakeholders in order to improve the performance of the Universal Health Coverage Scheme (UCS).
This study aims to explore the annual public hearing process, evaluate its effectiveness and propose recommendations for improvement.
In-depth interviews were conducted with 29 key informants from various stakeholder groups involved in annual public hearings.
The evaluation showed that the public hearings fully met the criteria of influence over policy decision and partially met the criteria of appropriate participation approach and social learning. However, there are rooms for improvement on public hearing's inclusiveness and representativeness of participants, adequacy of information and transparency.
Three recommendations were proposed a) informing stakeholders in advance of the agenda and hearing process to enable their active participation; b) identifying experienced facilitators to navigate the discussions across stakeholders with different or conflicting interests, in order to reach consensus and prioritize recommendations; and c) communicating policy and management responses as a result of public hearings to all stakeholders in a timely manner.
泰国 2002 年《国家健康保障法案》的立法规定要求为提供者、受益人及其他利益相关者举办年度公开听证会,以改进全民健康覆盖计划(UCS)的绩效。
本研究旨在探讨年度公开听证程序,评估其效果,并提出改进建议。
对参与年度公开听证会的 29 名来自不同利益相关群体的主要知情人进行了深入访谈。
评估结果显示,公开听证会完全符合影响政策决策的标准,部分符合适当参与方法和社会学习的标准。但是,在公开听证会参与者的包容性和代表性、信息和透明度方面还有改进的空间。
提出了三项建议:a)提前通知利益相关者议程和听证程序,使他们能够积极参与;b)确定有经验的主持人,以引导不同或利益冲突的利益相关者进行讨论,以达成共识和优先考虑建议;c)及时向所有利益相关者传达公开听证的政策和管理回应。