Helfgott Research Institute, National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, OR 97201, USA.
Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR 97239, USA.
Nutrients. 2020 Nov 4;12(11):3394. doi: 10.3390/nu12113394.
This systematic review and meta-analysis focused on randomized controlled trials (RCT) of multinutrients consisting of at least four vitamins and/or minerals as interventions for participants with psychiatric symptoms. A systematic search identified 16 RCTs that fit the inclusion criteria ( = 1719 participants) in six psychiatric categories: depression, post-disaster stress, antisocial behavior, behavioral deficits in dementia, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and autism. Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) was used to rate the evidence base. Significant clinical benefit was assessed using minimal clinically important differences (MIDs). Due to heterogeneity in participants, multinutrient formulas, outcome measures, and absence of complete data, only the Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) category was eligible for meta-analyses. In ADHD populations, statistically and clinically significant improvements were found in global functioning, Mean Difference (MD) -3.3, = 0.001, MID -3.26; Standardized Mean Difference (SMD) -0.49 = 0.001 MD -0.5), clinician ratings of global improvement (MD -0.58, = 0.001, MID -0.5) and ADHD improvement (MD -0.54, = 0.002, MID -0.5), and clinician (but not observer) measures of ADHD inattentive symptoms (MD -1.53, = 0.05, MID -0.5). Narrative synthesis also revealed a pattern of benefit for global measures of improvement, for example: in autism, and in participants with behavioral deficits in dementia. Post-natural disaster anxiety and the number of violent incidents in prison populations also improved. Broad-spectrum formulas (vitamins + minerals) demonstrated more robust effects than formulas with fewer ingredients. This review highlights the need for robust methodology-RCTs that report full data, including means and standard deviations for all outcomes-in order to further elucidate the effects of multinutrients for psychiatric symptoms.
本系统评价和荟萃分析专注于包含至少四种维生素和/或矿物质的多种营养素作为干预措施,以治疗有精神症状的参与者。通过系统搜索,确定了符合纳入标准的 16 项 RCT(=1719 名参与者),涉及六个精神科类别:抑郁、灾后应激、反社会行为、痴呆的行为缺陷、注意力缺陷/多动障碍和自闭症。使用推荐评估、制定与评估分级(GRADE)对证据基础进行评级。使用最小临床重要差异(MID)评估是否有显著的临床获益。由于参与者、多种营养素配方、结局测量以及数据不完整,只有注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)类别符合荟萃分析条件。在 ADHD 人群中,发现总体功能有统计学和临床意义的改善,均值差(MD)为-3.3,=0.001,MID-3.26;标准化均值差(SMD)为-0.49,=0.001,MD-0.5),临床医生对整体改善的评分(MD-0.58,=0.001,MID-0.5)和 ADHD 改善(MD-0.54,=0.002,MID-0.5),以及临床医生(而非观察者)的 ADHD 注意力不集中症状的评分(MD-1.53,=0.05,MID-0.5)。叙述性综合分析还揭示了改善总体措施的获益模式,例如:自闭症,痴呆行为缺陷患者。自然灾害后的焦虑和监狱人群中的暴力事件数量也有所改善。广谱配方(维生素+矿物质)的效果比成分较少的配方更显著。本综述强调需要进行稳健的方法学研究,即进行 RCT 并报告完整数据,包括所有结局的均值和标准差,以进一步阐明多种营养素对精神症状的影响。