Haslam Kimberly, Doucette Heather, Hachey Shauna, MacCallum Teanne, Zwicker Denise, Smith-Brilliant Martha, Gilbert Robert
School of Dental Hygiene, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
School of Health Sciences, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Can J Dent Hyg. 2019 Feb 1;53(1):53-66.
To determine the potential value of YouTube videos as health decision aids for the public.
An integrative review was performed to explore 3 questions: 1) What is the validity of health-related YouTube videos created for the public? 2) Are YouTube videos an effective tool for supporting the public in decision making regarding the treatment, prevention, and diagnosis of disease? 3) How can health professionals ensure their videos will be readily accessible to those searching online for health-related information? Systematic searches of PubMed, CINAHL, and Web of Science were conducted. The returns were screened using inclusion and exclusion criteria and studies found were critically appraised.
Fifty-eight studies assessed the validity of videos on given topics and 9 studies examined the effectiveness of videos in supporting decision making. These studies demonstrated that the majority of health-related YouTube videos lack validity. However, evidence-based videos do exist and have the potential to be an effective instrument in supporting the public in making health decisions. Ten studies examined ways to increase the accessibility of such videos to the public.
Creators of evidence-based videos must take into consideration content and content-agnostic factors to improve the accessibility of their videos to searchers. Recommendations to support creators in making their evidence-based health videos readily accessible to the public are provided.
By exploiting appropriate content and content-agnostic factors, video creators can ensure that valid health information is readily accessible to information seekers.
确定YouTube视频作为公众健康决策辅助工具的潜在价值。
进行了一项综合综述,以探讨3个问题:1)为公众制作的与健康相关的YouTube视频的有效性如何?2)YouTube视频是否是支持公众在疾病治疗、预防和诊断决策方面的有效工具?3)卫生专业人员如何确保他们的视频能让那些在网上搜索健康相关信息的人容易获取?对PubMed、CINAHL和科学网进行了系统检索。使用纳入和排除标准对检索结果进行筛选,并对找到的研究进行严格评估。
58项研究评估了特定主题视频的有效性,9项研究考察了视频在支持决策方面的有效性。这些研究表明,大多数与健康相关的YouTube视频缺乏有效性。然而,基于证据的视频确实存在,并且有可能成为支持公众做出健康决策的有效工具。10项研究探讨了提高此类视频对公众可及性的方法。
基于证据的视频创作者必须考虑内容和与内容无关的因素,以提高其视频对搜索者的可及性。提供了支持创作者使其基于证据的健康视频易于公众获取的建议。
通过利用适当的内容和与内容无关的因素,视频创作者可以确保信息寻求者能够容易获取有效的健康信息。