González-Fernández Doris, Mazzini Salom Ana Sofía, Herrera Bendezu Fermina, Huamán Sonia, Rojas Hernández Bertha, Pevec Illène, Galarza Izquierdo Eliana Mariana, Armstrong Nicoletta, Thomas Virginia, Vela Gonzáles Sonia, Gonzáles Saravia Carlos, Scott Marilyn E, Koski Kristine G
School of Human Nutrition, McGill University, Sainte Anne de Bellevue, QC, Canada.
International Child Development Program - ICDP Peru, Lima, Peru.
Front Public Health. 2020 Nov 6;8:567900. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2020.567900. eCollection 2020.
Multi-dimensional monitoring evaluation and learning strategies are needed to address the complex set of factors that affect early child development in marginalized populations, but few studies have explored their effectiveness. To compare improvement of health and development of children 0-3 years between intervention communities (IC) and control communities (CC) from peripheral settlements of Lima. Sequential interventions included: (1) home and community gardens, (2) conscious nutrition, and (3) parenting workshops following the International Child Development Program (ICDP). Interventions were delivered by community health promoters (CHPs) using a "step-by-step" learning system. Both IC and CC were monitored before the interventions began, at 8 and 12 months ( = 113 IC and 127 CC children). Data were collected on household characteristics, diet, food security, health indicators (history of diarrhea and respiratory infections, hemoglobin, intestinal parasites, anthropometry), caregiver-child interactions and stress, and achievement of Pan-American Health Organization age-specific developmental milestones. Stepwise multiple logistic regressions were used to determine if the interventions affected food insecurity, as well as motor, social/cognitive and language delays. At baseline, 2.6% were categorized as "suspected developmental delay" and 14.2% were on "alert for development delay." Food insecurity, diarrhea and respiratory infections were lowered following the interventions. Through the "step-by-step" approach, caregivers in IC gained skills in gardening, conscious nutrition and parenting that reduced the risk of food insecurity [Adjusted Risk Ratio = 0.20 (95% CI: 0.08-0.51)] and language delay [0.39 (0.19-0.82)] but not motor or social/cognitive delay. Use of a multiple micronutrient supplement decreased the risk of motor delay [0.12 (0.03-0.56)], but more pets were associated with higher risk of motor [3.24 (1.47-7.14)] and social/cognitive delay [2.72 (1.33-5.55)], and of food insecurity [1.73 (1.13-2.66)]. The combined interventions delivered by CHPs helped to mitigate the impact of adversity on food insecurity and language delay. Additional improvements may have been detected if the interventions had continued for a longer time. Our results indicate that control of infections and pets may be needed to achieve measurable results for motor and social/cognitive development. Continuous monitoring facilitated adjusting implementation strategies and achieving positive developmental outcomes.
需要采用多维监测评估和学习策略来应对影响边缘化人群儿童早期发育的一系列复杂因素,但很少有研究探讨其有效性。为比较利马周边定居点干预社区(IC)和对照社区(CC)中0至3岁儿童的健康和发育改善情况。连续干预措施包括:(1)家庭和社区花园;(2)有意识的营养;(3)遵循国际儿童发展计划(ICDP)举办育儿工作坊。干预措施由社区健康促进者(CHP)通过“逐步”学习系统实施。在干预开始前、8个月和12个月时对IC和CC进行监测(IC组113名儿童,CC组127名儿童)。收集了有关家庭特征、饮食、食品安全、健康指标(腹泻和呼吸道感染史、血红蛋白、肠道寄生虫、人体测量)、照顾者与儿童的互动及压力,以及泛美卫生组织特定年龄发育里程碑达成情况的数据。采用逐步多元逻辑回归来确定干预措施是否影响粮食不安全以及运动、社交/认知和语言发育迟缓。在基线时,2.6%被归类为“疑似发育迟缓”,14.2%处于“发育迟缓警戒”状态。干预后,粮食不安全、腹泻和呼吸道感染情况有所改善。通过“逐步”方法,IC组的照顾者在园艺、有意识的营养和育儿方面获得了技能,降低了粮食不安全风险[调整风险比 = 0.20(95%置信区间:0.08 - 0.51)]和语言发育迟缓风险[0.39(0.19 - 0.82)],但对运动或社交/认知发育迟缓没有影响。使用多种微量营养素补充剂降低了运动发育迟缓风险[0.12(0.03 - 0.56)],但更多的宠物与运动发育迟缓[3.24(1.47 - 7.14)]、社交/认知发育迟缓[2.72(1.33 - 5.55)]以及粮食不安全风险[1.73(1.13 - 2.66)]升高有关。CHP实施的综合干预措施有助于减轻逆境对粮食不安全和语言发育迟缓的影响。如果干预持续更长时间,可能会发现更多改善情况。我们的结果表明,可能需要控制感染和宠物数量,才能在运动和社交/认知发育方面取得可衡量的成果。持续监测有助于调整实施策略并实现积极的发育成果。