Curran Orlaith, MacNamara Aine, Passmore David
School of Health and Human Performance, Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland.
Institute for Sport and Health, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Front Sports Act Living. 2019 Jul 11;1:3. doi: 10.3389/fspor.2019.00003. eCollection 2019.
Although there is an extensive literature about talent development, the lack of data pertaining to females is problematic. Indeed, the gender data gap can be seen in practically all domains including sport and exercise medicine. Evidence-based practice is the systematic reviewing of the best evidence in order to make informed choices about practice. Unfortunately, it may be that the data collected in sport is typically about male experiences, and not female; a rather unfortunate omission given that approximately half of the population is made up of women. When female athletes are underrepresented in research there are issues when making inferences about data collected in male dominated research domains to inform practice and policy for female athletes. In parallel, female sport participation is continually increasing worldwide. Recognizing the importance of evidence-based practice in driving policy and practice, and reflecting the gender data gap that is a consistent feature of (almost) all other domains, we were interested in examining whether a gender data gap exists in talent development research. The results suggest that a gender data gap exists in talent development research across all topics. Youth athlete development pathways may be failing to recognize the development requirements of females, particularly where female sports may be borrowing systems that are perceived to work for their male counterparts. In order to ensure robust evidence based practice in female youth sport there is a need to increase the visibility of female athletes in talent development literature.
尽管有大量关于人才发展的文献,但缺乏与女性相关的数据是个问题。事实上,性别数据差距在包括体育和运动医学在内的几乎所有领域都存在。循证实践是对最佳证据进行系统审查,以便对实践做出明智的选择。不幸的是,体育领域收集的数据可能通常是关于男性的经历,而非女性的;鉴于大约一半的人口是女性,这是一个相当不幸的遗漏。当女性运动员在研究中的代表性不足时,在将男性主导的研究领域中收集的数据推断用于为女性运动员制定实践和政策时就会出现问题。与此同时,全球女性参与体育运动的人数在持续增加。认识到循证实践在推动政策和实践方面的重要性,并反映出(几乎)所有其他领域都存在的性别数据差距,我们有兴趣研究人才发展研究中是否存在性别数据差距。结果表明,在所有主题的人才发展研究中都存在性别数据差距。青少年运动员的发展路径可能未能认识到女性的发展需求,特别是在女性体育项目可能借鉴被认为适用于男性同行的体系的情况下。为了确保在女子青少年体育中进行有力的循证实践,有必要提高女性运动员在人才发展文献中的能见度。