Elizabeth G. Klein, Associate Professor, The Ohio State University College of Public Health, Columbus, OH, United States;, Email:
Mahmood A. Alalwan, Student Research Assistant, The Ohio State University College of Public Health, Columbus, OH, United States.
Am J Health Behav. 2021 Jan 1;45(1):186-194. doi: 10.5993/AJHB.45.1.15.
The purpose of this study was to select a health warning message location on a waterpipe (WP) that both attracted visual attention and conveyed the risks associated with WP smoking. During June through November 2019, we conducted a within-subjects randomized experiment (N = 74) using eye tracking equipment to examine visual attention to 3 placements of a health warning on the WP (stem, water bowl, hose). We asked young adult ever WP users 3 questions about WP harm perceptions. We used generalized linear mixed models to examine the amount of fixation time spent on the placement locations; we used repeated measures ANOVA to model changes in harm perceptions. There were statistically significant differences across all 3 placement locations; regardless of place, all HWLs attracted a comparable amount of visual attention. Absolute WP harm perceptions significantly increased following the experiment and remained significantly higher at the one-week follow-up, compared to baseline. Warnings on WPs attracted visual attention and increased harm perceptions, and those harm perceptions remained high one week after the experiment. Findings indicate the value of including a warning on the WP device, and underscore the necessity and effectiveness of those health warnings to combat WP harm misperceptions.
本研究的目的是选择水烟管(WP)上的健康警示信息位置,既要吸引视觉注意,又要传达与 WP 吸烟相关的风险。在 2019 年 6 月至 11 月期间,我们使用眼动跟踪设备进行了一项组内随机实验(N=74),以检查对 WP 上 3 个健康警示位置(烟嘴、水碗、吸嘴)的视觉注意。我们向年轻的成年 WP 用户询问了 3 个关于 WP 危害感知的问题。我们使用广义线性混合模型来检查在放置位置上花费的注视时间量;我们使用重复测量 ANOVA 来模拟危害感知的变化。在所有 3 个放置位置都存在统计学上的显著差异;无论放置位置如何,所有的 HWL 都吸引了相当数量的视觉注意。与基线相比,实验后绝对 WP 危害感知显著增加,并且在一周随访时仍然显著更高。WP 上的警告吸引了视觉注意并增加了危害感知,并且这些危害感知在实验一周后仍保持较高水平。研究结果表明,在 WP 设备上包含警告具有价值,并强调了这些健康警告对抗 WP 危害误解的必要性和有效性。